Skip to content
Goshen Exchange

AgricultureLesson 7 of 8

Hay and winter feed

Breakout About 7 min readNew to you

What you’ll learn

  • How much hay an animal needs for the winter, and how waste changes the total
  • How rings and racks cut waste compared with feeding on the ground
  • How to judge hay by sight and smell, and what a hay test tells you
  • How to store bales, and what to do when a stack heats up
  • Which forage problems poison livestock: nitrate, botulism, blister beetles and herbicide carryover

The short version

  1. Hay baled over 20% moisture (18% for round bales) can heat and burn. Check bale temperature twice a day for six weeks and call the fire department at 175°F.

  2. Test hay before you buy it, and test any drought or frost-stressed forage for nitrate. Drying doesn't lower nitrate.

  3. Feed hay in a ring or rack, not on the ground. Unrestricted feeding wastes 25 to 45%.

How much hay

AnimalAbout
Beef cow2.0 to 2.5% of body weight in dry matter a day (1.5 to 1.8% on poor hay alone); 2.5 to 3.5% offered as hay in winter
1,200 lb cow23.3 lb mid-gestation; 24.1 late; 27.8 early lactation (dry matter)
Horse2 to 2.5%; 1,000 lb horse about 20 lb a day, 12 fifty-lb bales a month
Sheep and goats2 to 4%; 4 to 6 lb hay per ewe in lactation

Math examples: a 1,400 lb cow eating about 41 lb a day for 120 days needs 2.46 tons, and at 20% loss 5,904 lb of harvested hay; a horse for 121 days (Dec 1 to Mar 31) needs about 2,420 lb, or about 67 forty-lb bales with 5% storage and 5% feeding waste. Montana's rule of thumb is one ton per cow for 60 to 70 days. Winter feeding days vary widely, from 60 to 180 in the examples, so work out your own from your frost dates. Cold raises need: 5 to 10% more at 22 to 5°F and 8 to 25% more below 5°F.

Match hay to the animal: dry cows early in gestation can use hay near 10% crude protein, while the best hay goes to late-gestation and early-lactation cows.

Diagram coming soonHay bale math
Figure 1. A cow, a ton and the 20% loss example.
Sources: University of Wisconsin Extension, University of Missouri Extension and 9 more

Feeding without waste

Unrestricted hay on the ground wastes 25 to 45%. A rack or ring with a restricted supply loses about 5 to 10%.

Feeder (cattle)Loss
Ring without a panel20%
Cradle15%
Feeder wagon11.5%
Ring with a panel6%
Cone with a panel3%

With no ring, figure one cow per foot of bale diameter per day; a ring holds about 10 cows, and a 30-cow herd uses one 900 lb bale a day. Hay rings cost about $125 each in a 2017 text. For horses, small-square feeder waste is 1% (slat), 3% (basket), 5% (rack) and 13% (no feeder), and round bales with no feeder lose 57%.

Sources: Ohio State University Extension, University of Missouri Extension and 2 more

Judging and testing hay

  • Sight and smell: bright green is best; golden-yellow on the outside only is acceptable; yellow all through means over-mature; brown, musty or caked hay is unacceptable. Put your nose in the middle of the bale and look for foreign matter (tansy ragwort, larkspur, wire).

  • Test it: sample by lot (one field, one cutting, baled within 48 hours) with a probe 12 to 24 inches long and at least 20 cores from random bales (Mississippi State says 15 to 20 round bales or at least 10 squares). A crude protein, ADF and NDF test costs about $15 to $50 (a price from the article's date), and turnaround runs a week or more.

  • Grades: grass hay is excellent over 58% TDN and 12% protein, good at 55 to 57% and 10 to 11%, fair at 52 to 54% and 8 to 9%, poor below. Relative feed value is for comparing lots, not balancing rations.

Sources: Oregon State University Extension, Mississippi State University Extension and 1 more

Storing hay

Where a round bale sits decides how much you lose. In a Tennessee trial, bales stored on the ground uncovered lost 37%, on tires uncovered 29%, on the ground covered 29%, net-wrapped on the ground 19%, on tires covered 8% and in a barn 6%. Minnesota says indoor storage cuts losses by two-thirds and net wrap cut grass-hay loss 32% against twine. Store on a 4 to 6 inch coarse rock base, never under trees, in rows end to end at least 3 ft apart. The outer 4 inches of a 6-ft bale is about 21% of its dry matter.

Diagram coming soonStorage losses
Figure 2. How much hay is lost by storage method.
Diagram coming soonHay-fire thermometer
Figure 3. The bale temperature table, from 125 to 200°F, with the action at each step.
Sources: University of Georgia Extension, University of Minnesota Extension and 5 more

Toxic and problem forage

  • Blister beetles in alfalfa can kill horses (the minimum lethal dose is about 1 mg of cantharidin per 2.2 lb); dead beetles stay toxic. Cut before 5% bloom and don't feed horses hay from infested field sections.

  • Ergot on grass seedheads in cool, damp springs: test hay baled after heading; 100 to 200 ppb ergot alkaloids can hurt performance.

  • Tansy ragwort in hay causes cumulative liver damage that can show up 6 months later; it grows in coastal Washington, Oregon, northern California and New England.

  • Mold: hay baled at 20 to 35% moisture or rained on carries higher mold risk; a mold count over 1,000,000 cfu per gram calls for a mycotoxin screen.

  • Herbicide carryover: aminopyralid, clopyralid and picloram pass through animals and survive composting for months to over a year. Maine says labels forbid moving treated hay, bedding or manure off the treated farm. Ask the grower what was sprayed.

  • Prussic acid and fescue are two more forage hazards to ask your extension office about.

Diagram coming soonNitrate decision
Figure 4. A nitrate test result and what to do with it.
Sources: Montana State University Extension, Kansas State University and 12 more

When hay runs short

For beef cows, corn replaces hay at about 1 lb per 2 lb on a TDN basis, 4 lb of soy hulls from December to March saved about 625 lb of hay per cow, wheat straw runs about 4.2% protein and corn stalks 3 to 7%; transition slowly. For horses, beet pulp can replace up to 55% of the forage and soy hulls up to 75%, weighed dry. No Tier 1 limits exist for goats and sheep. Grass straw for horses can carry endophyte toxins.

Regional notes: Pennsylvania second cut at 35 to 40 days; Alabama bermudagrass every 4 to 5 weeks; low-desert Arizona alfalfa 6 to 8 cuttings; western Oregon and Washington wet-weather haymaking with 5 to 50% field loss.

Sources: University of Wisconsin Extension, Ohio State University Extension and 4 more

Costs

ItemAboutNotes
Hay ringabout $125 each2017 text
Hay test (protein, ADF, NDF)about $15 to $50Price from the article's date
Sources: University of Missouri Extension, Mississippi State University Extension

Common mistakes

  1. Baling hay over 20% moisture, or never probing the stack in the first six weeks.

  2. Feeding hay on the ground.

  3. Feeding drought or frost-stressed forage untested.

Sources: Mississippi State University Extension, Farm and Ranch eXtension in Safety and Health and 4 more

Troubleshooting

What you seeLikely causeWhat to do
Hay stack warm or steamingHeating from moistureProbe; follow the NRAES table; fire department at 175°F
Cows abort after drought hayNitrateTest hay; vet
Moldy, musty hayBaled wet or rained onDon't feed to horses or pregnant animals; test
Hay ring empty every dayWaste or too few ringsAdd a ring; restrict supply
Sources: South Dakota State University Extension, Farm and Ranch eXtension in Safety and Health and 5 more

Resources

By zone

Cold raises how much hay you need, and hay quality problems and cutting schedules differ by region.

3–4
Cold raises feed need 5 to 25%.
7–8
Humid-baling fire risk.
Northeast
Tansy ragwort in hay. Second cut at 35 to 40 days.
Southeast
Bermudagrass hay every 4 to 5 weeks.
Midwest
Nitrate risk in drought.
Southwest
Irrigated alfalfa gives 6 to 8 cuttings. Blister beetles.
Pacific Northwest
Wet-weather haymaking. Tansy ragwort.
Mountain West
Montana hay rule. Cereal hay nitrate.

Where this comes from

Every fact in this lesson was checked against 45 published sources, all from extension services, the USDA and research journals. Each section lists its own at the bottom.

See all 45 sources
Farm and Ranch eXtension in Safety and Health
Maine Board of Pesticides Control
Ontario Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs
University of Maryland Extension
University of Minnesota Extension
University of Wisconsin-Madison Nutrient and Pest Management Program
USDA Agricultural Research Service

Summary

The whole lesson on one page. Print it or come back to it.

Key information

  • Plan by body weight. Beef cows need 2.0 to 2.5% of body weight in dry matter a day, and cold raises the need: 5 to 10% more at 22 to 5°F and 8 to 25% more below 5°F.
  • Feed from a ring or rack. Unrestricted hay on the ground wastes 25 to 45%; a rack or ring with a restricted supply loses about 5 to 10%.
  • Test before you buy. Sample by lot with a probe, taking at least 20 cores from random bales.
  • Moisture decides fire risk. Bale small squares at 20% moisture or less and large rounds at 18% or less.
  • Probe hay that was baled wet. Check bale temperature twice a day for six weeks, and call the fire department at 175°F.
  • Test drought- or frost-stressed forage for nitrate. Drying does not lower the nitrate in hay.

Step by step

  1. 1.Work out your winter feeding days from your frost dates, then add waste to the hay you need.
  2. 2.Look and smell inside the bale, and test the lot, before you buy.
  3. 3.Store bales off the ground on a coarse rock base, in rows with space between them.
  4. 4.Probe wet-baled hay twice a day for the first six weeks.
  5. 5.Feed from a ring or rack and restrict the supply.

Made it to the end? I’ll keep track for you on this device.