Skip to content
Goshen Exchange

PreservationLesson 7 of 7

Dairy and cheese

Breakout About 30 min readNew to you

What you’ll learn

  • How to get clean milk from your animal and cool it fast
  • How to pasteurize milk at home on the stovetop or in jars
  • What the evidence says about raw milk, and how state laws differ
  • How to make yogurt, kefir and butter safely, and why never to can butter
  • Simple cheeses, the 60-day aging rule and what to do about mold

The short version

  1. Cool fast. Commercial Grade A milk is cooled to 50°F within 4 hours and 45°F within 2 more. States that allow raw milk for people use stricter numbers, mostly 40°F within 2 hours. For milk you will drink, use an ice bath and aim for 40°F within 2 hours, the stricter state rule.

  2. Pasteurize in a double boiler or in jars in a canner. Hold 161°F for 15 seconds with constant stirring, or 145°F for 30 minutes, then chill in ice water to 40°F or below.

  3. Discard milk from a treated animal for the period on the drug label or set by your veterinarian.

  4. Raw milk outbreaks are well documented. CDC and FDA counted 202 raw milk outbreaks, 2,645 illnesses, 228 hospitalizations and 3 deaths from 1998 to 2018, against 9 outbreaks and 2,133 illnesses for pasteurized milk.

  5. Testing cannot prove safety. FDA says coliform and somatic cell counts "do not provide information on the presence or absence of pathogens".

  6. Yogurt: heat pasteurized milk to 180°F (WSU) or 185 to 200°F (Alaska, Utah State) for 10 to 20 minutes, cool to about 108 to 115°F, add starter, hold 4 to 8 hours near 100 to 112°F until set near pH 4.6, then refrigerate.

  7. Butter: churn cream at 52 to 66°F depending on season, wash in cold water, salt at 3/4 ounce per pound. Butter must be at least 80 percent milkfat by law. There is no Tier 1 source saying raw-cream home butter is safe.

  8. Home cheese milk: use 145°F for 30 minutes if heating raw milk (PNW 539), and never ultra-pasteurized milk.

Getting clean milk

The routine

Penn State's routine is dip, strip, dry and attach, with the milking unit or your hands on within 60 to 120 seconds of first stimulating the teats. Pre-dip stays on for 15 to 20 seconds per its label and is not wiped off immediately. Strip 3 to 5 squirts per teat for at least 10 seconds to check the foremilk. University of Georgia gives 30 seconds of germicide contact; both defer to the product label. Pre-milking teat sanitizing is only about 40 to 50 percent effective against environmental bacteria, so the dry udder matters more than the dip. Keep the cow standing for about an hour after milking so the teat canal can close.

Abnormal milk and mastitis

The PMO says milk from an animal with abnormal milk in a quarter is milked last or with separate equipment and discarded. Bloody, stringy or off-colored milk is kept away from other animals and utensils. University of Georgia (2026) gives some numbers worth knowing before you treat anything: infections clear on their own in only about 20 percent of cases, and when drugs are used as labeled the cure rates in lactation are 90 to 95 percent for Strep. agalactiae, 20 to 30 percent for Staph. aureus and 0 to 10 percent for coliforms. Mycoplasma, yeasts and Prototheca do not respond. Treatment during lactation is indicated at a herd somatic cell count above 200,000 or with clinical mastitis, and most acute-case treatment is extra-label and needs a veterinarian. This lesson does not print doses; the label and your vet govern.

Somatic cell count

The PMO legal limit for an individual producer's cow milk is 750,000 cells per mL and for goat milk 1,500,000 per mL (2023 and 2025). A 2006 Dairy Practices Council text gave 1,000,000 for goats. Many farms aim under 200,000, and high counts shorten shelf life, hurt cheese and cause rancid, salty or bitter flavor. The 200,000 figure is a treatment threshold, not a legal limit. The California Mastitis Test is the on-farm screen.

Sources: Code of Federal Regulations (eCFR), FDA / National Conference on Interstate Milk Shipments and 5 more

Cooling milk

StandardCooling
PMO Grade A (for pasteurization)50°F in 4 hours, then 45°F within 2 more
Virginia dairy farms40°F within 2 hours; never above 50°F
Massachusetts retail raw milk40°F or less within 2 hours
Vermont, Delaware40°F within 2 hours
South Carolina, Georgia raw milk50°F in 4 hours; 45°F within 2
Kentucky goat milk36–40°F within 2 hours
Washington 2011 retail raw guide40°F within 2 hours
Montana guide1 hour on one page, 2 hours on another

The sources disagree, so this table is a menu of rules rather than one number. For a family cow, an ice bath with stirring, smaller containers such as half-gallon jars and a written log of temperature and time are the methods the Montana and Washington guides give. Goat milk is advised to be cooled to 36 to 40°F and held there, with 45°F as the legal maximum in a 2006 bulletin. A 2004 Virginia bulletin gives a farm target of 40°F within 30 minutes.

Diagram coming soonCooling ladder
Figure 1. Cooling ladder: the commercial rule against the strict 2-hour rule.
Sources: FDA / National Conference on Interstate Milk Shipments, Virginia Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services and 10 more

Cleaning and sanitizing

Steps (University of Florida, small dairy, 2024)

  1. Rinse right after milking with 100 to 110°F water. Below 93°F milk fat deposits; above 120°F protein films build.

  2. Wash with chlorinated alkaline detergent at 120 to 135°F for at least 5 minutes.

  3. Post-rinse with 100 to 110°F water.

  4. Acid rinse with a cold acid solution at pH 3.0 to 4.0 for 2 to 3 minutes.

  5. Sanitize before the next use. The PMO says product-contact surfaces are cleaned after each milking and sanitized before each use, by 170°F water for at least 5 minutes or by labeled chemicals used "in accordance with label directions." It prints no chlorine strength for routine equipment.

Penn State's bleach article reports one product label at 200 ppm available chlorine with at least 2 minutes of contact at 75°F; contact time doubles for every 18°F colder, so about 4 minutes at 57°F. Do not use bleach on teats. Follow the label on the bleach you actually own.

Diagram coming soonWash sequence
Figure 2. Four wash stages with their temperatures.
Sources: University of Florida IFAS Extension, FDA / National Conference on Interstate Milk Shipments and 1 more

Pasteurizing at home

What the federal definition says

21 CFR 1240.61 (read live on eCFR on 2026-10-06) defines pasteurization as heating every particle of milk in properly designed and operated equipment to 145°F for 30 minutes, 161°F for 15 seconds, or 191°F for 1 second, held continuously, with shorter times at 194 to 212°F. Raise the temperature 5°F if the product has 10 percent fat or more or added sweeteners. Eggnog is 155°F for 30 minutes. The PMO calls the 30-minute method "batch (vat)" and the 15-second method "continuous flow (HTST)". This is an interstate rule; selling raw milk inside a state is a state matter.

Stovetop (Oregon State, 2025)

Materials: a double boiler or a saucepan set in a larger pan of water, an accurate metal-stem thermometer, a long spoon, a sink of ice water.

  1. Fill the bottom pan with water and put the milk in the top pan or saucepan.

  2. Stir constantly while heating.

  3. Hold 161°F for 15 seconds, or 145°F for 30 minutes. If the temperature drops below 145°F the 30 minutes starts again.

  4. Set the pan in ice water and stir until cold.

Ohio State (2025) has the thermometer and a spoon stay in the milk the whole time, switches to ice water when the milk is under 130°F and finishes at 40°F or below. Its jar method fills jars four-fifths full, holds them in a canner at 145°F for 30 minutes (reheat if it drops), cools by replacing the hot water gradually to 80°F or less, then to 40°F or colder with ice water.

What pasteurizing does not do

Ohio State cites 99.999 percent of pathogens destroyed, and Penn State says very high-bacteria milk may let some survive. Pasteurizer failures come from unclean equipment, not enough hot water and recontamination after heating. A small research finding for waste milk: holding at 149°F for 10 minutes destroyed common mastitic mycoplasmas and 175.5°F for 30 minutes destroyed Johne's bacteria, but those are not legal pasteurization equivalents.

Diagram coming soonDouble boiler setup
Figure 3. A double boiler, a thermometer in the milk and a sink of ice water.
Sources: Code of Federal Regulations (eCFR), FDA / National Conference on Interstate Milk Shipments and 5 more

Storing milk

  • Refrigerator: about 37°F toward the back, not in the door; storage above 40°F shortens shelf life. Clemson (2007) says pasteurized milk keeps 1 to 5 days past the sell-by date, about two weeks in all. No Tier 1 page gives days for raw or home-pasteurized milk.

  • Freezer: freeze pasteurized milk at 0°F with 1/2 to 1 1/2 inches of headspace, thaw in the refrigerator, shake or blend. A yellow tinge is riboflavin and is harmless. Use thawed milk within a few days; Nebraska says use frozen milk within a month for best quality. Freezing does not destroy microbes, so frozen raw milk is not made safe. Goat milk keeps about 3 months frozen per an Arkansas Extension blog.

  • Power outage: milk, cream, sour cream, buttermilk and yogurt above 40°F for more than 2 hours are to be discarded. A closed refrigerator holds about 4 hours and a full freezer about 48 hours.

Sources: Ohio State University Extension, Clemson Extension and 4 more

Common milking and pasteurizing mistakes

  1. Cooling in the refrigerator instead of an ice bath.

  2. Trusting a dial thermometer you never checked.

  3. Letting the milk dip below 145°F and not restarting the clock.

  4. Pasteurizing soured milk.

  5. Using milk from a treated animal.

  6. Washing in water below 93°F or above 120°F during the first rinse.

  7. Inventing a bleach strength rather than reading the label.

  8. Treating the 200,000 cell count as a law.

Sources: Montana Department of Public Health and Human Services, Washington State Department of Agriculture, Food Safety Program and 6 more

What the evidence says

Pathogens and how they get in

FDA's longest list names Campylobacter, Cryptosporidium, E. coli (STEC), Listeria, Brucella, Salmonella, Mycobacterium bovis, Coxiella burnetii (Q fever), Yersinia enterocolitica and Staphylococcus aureus. They get in from manure, the udder (mastitis) and equipment, and animals can shed STEC and Cryptosporidium while healthy. Minnesota's health department says milk can carry germs "no matter how well the animals are cared for and how clean the operation is". CDC and FDA's analysis of 2013 to 2018 outbreaks found that strict milking sanitation did not significantly reduce illnesses or outbreaks.

Outbreak numbers (each with its own period)

SourcePeriodCount
CDC and FDA, Koski1998–2018202 raw milk outbreaks, 2,645 illnesses, 228 hospitalizations, 3 deaths
Washington health department1998–2023247 outbreaks, 3,141 illnesses, 289 hospitalizations, 2 deaths
CDC, Mungai2007–201281 outbreaks, 979 illnesses, 73 hospitalizations; 81% in legal-sale states
CDC, Langer1993–200660% of patients under 20; hospitalization 13% vs 1% for pasteurized
FDA older pagessince 1987 / to 2010143 outbreaks; 133 through September 2010

These differ by period and by whether cheese is counted, so quote each with its dates. In 2013 to 2018 raw milk outbreaks were 49 percent Campylobacter, 17 percent Salmonella, 15 percent STEC and 11 percent Cryptosporidium, and 14 percent of ill people were under 5 and 34 percent were 5 to 19. An earlier 2007 to 2012 study put Campylobacter at 77 percent of outbreaks, so shares move with the period.

Costard and colleagues estimated that raw milk and cheese, eaten by about 3.2 and 1.6 percent of people, caused 840 times more illnesses and 45 times more hospitalizations than pasteurized dairy. That compares total outbreak-related illnesses, not risk per glass.

Licensed and small-herd outbreaks

  • California 2023–2024: a permitted, tested producer caused 171 Salmonella cases, 70 percent in people under 18, 22 hospitalized, with 82 percent of cases in September and October. Aged raw cheese tested positive too. The same producer was linked to a 2025–2026 E. coli O157:H7 outbreak: 9 cases in 3 states, 67 percent under 5. FDA found one cheddar sample positive for E. coli O157:H7, but sequencing showed a different strain from the sick people.

  • Pennsylvania: a dairy that tested more often than required had outbreaks in 2012 (148 cases) and 2013. Pennsylvania had 17 outbreaks from 2005 to 2013.

  • Washington: licensed dairies, tested monthly, had STEC outbreaks in 2024, 2025 and 2026. In 2025 and 2026 the routine sample was negative, so there was no recall.

  • Tennessee 2022: a cow share of 7 to 10 hand-milked cows (members in Georgia, Tennessee and North Carolina) caused STEC O157:H7 in two infants, and milk and barn manure strains matched.

  • Colorado 2016 and Michigan 2010: herd share outbreaks (17 Campylobacter cases with a resistant strain, and a Michigan outbreak from cow-share milk) at times when cow-share milk was legal but unregulated.

  • Idaho 2015: 11 Cryptosporidium cases from a licensed goat dairy, with the milk source never confirmed in the lab.

  • Minnesota: 2001–2010 surveillance found 3.7 percent of sporadic enteric cases reported raw milk, 76 percent of children under 5 got it from their own or a relative's farm, and 21 percent of raw-milk STEC O157 patients developed HUS. 35 percent of cases came in June to August.

Seasons do not make it safe: Washington had STEC cases in January to March 2024.

What testing can and cannot show

FDA says the inability of a method to detect pathogens "does not indicate the absence of pathogens," that it does not believe HACCP can ensure raw milk safety, and its 21 CFR 1240.61 rule found routine testing for all pathogens not feasible. A 20-study FDA meta-analysis put bulk-tank prevalence at 4.3 percent Listeria, 3.6 percent Salmonella, 4.3 percent STEC and 6.0 percent Campylobacter. USDA's 2014 NAHMS survey of 234 dairies in 17 states found Salmonella on 18.0 percent of operations, Listeria monocytogenes on 3.0 percent and Campylobacter on 24.9 percent, higher in the West (45.9 percent) than the East (22.6 percent). Operations with 30 to 99 cows had less Campylobacter (6.5 percent) than operations with 100 to 499 cows (42.8 percent), but no one-cow herds were sampled, so do not read that as "small is safe".

H5N1 bird flu and raw milk

As of FDA's page current to March 14, 2025, 464 pasteurized dairy products tested negative for viable virus, and HTST at 161°F for 15 seconds inactivated H5N1 in 9 of 9 runs in a commercial-style unit. NIAID bench tests did not fully inactivate the virus at 72°C for 15 and 20 seconds, and FDA says benchtop equipment does not simulate HTST. The virus is stable in cold milk (half-life 2.1 days at 4°C), raw milk from infected cows made mice sick, and virus survived 120 days of cheese aging at pH 6.6 and 5.8 but not at pH 5.0. California recalled all Raw Farm milk and cream in November 2024 after H5N1 was found at retail and at the bottling plant. CDC reported 71 US human H5 cases since February 2024 as of March 6, 2026 and calls public risk low. The National Milk Testing Strategy mostly samples milk going to pasteurizing plants, so a family cow or small raw milk farm is outside it unless the owner joins voluntarily. APHIS counts and maps change weekly; check the live page.

Diagram coming soonOutbreak bars
Figure 4. Raw milk and pasteurized milk outbreaks, 1998 to 2018.
Sources: CDC, U.S. Food and Drug Administration and 12 more

The law

Federal

21 CFR 1240.61(a) bars delivering into interstate commerce, selling or holding for sale after interstate shipment, milk or milk products in final package form for direct human consumption unless pasteurized, except where another rule provides an alternative, such as part 133 for curing certain cheeses. 21 CFR 1240.3 counts milk from cows, goats, sheep and water buffalo and products such as yogurt, kefir, butter and cheese. FDA says it does not regulate intrastate sale (states decide), will not act against an individual carrying raw milk across state lines solely for personal consumption, and counted 20 states prohibiting and 30 allowing intrastate sale in some form on a page current as of March 5, 2024. The Grade A PMO (2025 revision) is a model ordinance states adopt; it covers Grade A raw milk for pasteurization, not retail raw milk. In US v. Allgyer (E.D. Pa., 2012) a federal court called a farm's cow-sharing agreements "merely a subterfuge" for interstate distribution; the case concerned interstate shipment, not in-state shares.

State by state (a quick map, as read 2026-10-06)

The patterns:

PatternStates
Farm sale or direct sale, little or no licenceMontana (small dairy, no license), Wyoming (Food Freedom Act), New Hampshire (under 20 gallons a day), North Dakota, Alaska (free registration), Kansas, Nebraska, Oklahoma (up to 1,500 gallons a month, 2026)
Permit or license requiredTexas, California, Pennsylvania, New York, Arizona, Washington, Idaho, Nevada (county certified), New Mexico, South Dakota, Vermont (two tier), Massachusetts, Connecticut, Maine, Delaware, South Carolina, Georgia, Illinois
Herd or cow share onlyColorado, Tennessee (personal use), Oregon (no sale or sampling)
Limited by animals or productIowa (10 or fewer animals), Missouri (farm sale for own use), Kentucky (goat milk with a physician note), Mississippi (incidental goat milk), Arkansas (on farm, markets, stores, 2025), West Virginia (legal with label, 2024), Utah (HB179, 2026)
Prohibited or pasteurized onlyAlabama, Louisiana, Florida, North Carolina, Maryland, Virginia, New Jersey (aged cheese excepted), Rhode Island (goat milk by prescription), Ohio, Indiana, Michigan, Wisconsin, Minnesota, Hawaii

Some details that trip people up:

  • Maine has no volume-based exemption from dairy licensing (the DACF FAQ, June 2026), although search snippets and old bills describe a 20-gallon exemption; Maine is treated as licensed.

  • Pennsylvania added a raw milk butter permit and made herd shares count as sales in rules effective May 23, 2026; enforcement against existing permit holders waits until May 23, 2027.

  • Oklahoma's 2026 law lifted the monthly cap from 100 to 1,500 gallons and allows advertising, but its wording still says "goat milk" in one subsection, so its reach to cow milk is unclear.

  • Louisiana only regulates raw milk as labeled feed; advocacy pages that say human sales became legal were not trusted.

  • Indiana bars advertising raw milk for people, not just selling it.

  • Idaho limits a herd share to 7 cows, 15 goats or 15 sheep and fines violations $200.

  • Washington counts a cow share as a sale.

Herd shares and cow shares

Treatment varies: written into statute or recognized in Connecticut, Idaho, Colorado, Alaska, North Dakota, Tennessee (personal use only) and Oregon (no sale or sampling); counted as sales needing a permit in Pennsylvania, Delaware, Nevada and Washington; not recognized in Georgia; barter prohibited in Virginia; and in Ohio the statute bars sale while one trial court (2006) upheld herd shares. A share is still raw milk: the Tennessee, Colorado and Michigan outbreaks above came from shares.

Diagram coming soonState map
Figure 5. Five kinds of state rule, from farm sale to prohibited.
Sources: Code of Federal Regulations (eCFR), U.S. Food and Drug Administration and 57 more

If you keep a milk animal and are deciding

  • Know your state's rule first. The state agency pages were read on 2026-10-06.

  • Understand who is at risk. If anyone in the household is a child under 5, pregnant, over 65 or immunocompromised, the agencies advise against raw milk.

  • Heat it. Utah's health department tells raw-milk drinkers to heat to 165°F for at least 15 seconds then cool; the federal numbers are in the pasteurizing section above.

  • Cool it fast and keep it cold. 40°F within 2 hours is the rule in several states.

  • Clean and test your own animal's milk for udder health and do not use milk from animals with mastitis or on treatment.

  • Do not feed raw milk to cats.

Sources: Code of Federal Regulations (eCFR), U.S. Food and Drug Administration and 9 more

Common raw milk mistakes

  1. Believing a license or a clean farm makes raw milk safe.

  2. Assuming a herd share is legal everywhere.

  3. Giving raw milk to children, pregnant relatives or older relatives.

  4. Feeding raw milk to pets.

  5. Trusting a negative test.

  6. Believing the 60-day cheese rule makes raw cheese safe.

  7. Using an advocacy page for your state's law instead of the agency.

  8. Advertising raw milk in Indiana.

Sources: CDC, Pennsylvania Department of Agriculture and 8 more

If someone gets sick or the rule is unclear

ProblemWhat the sources sayWhat to do
Someone drank raw milk and has bloody diarrhea, fever over 102°F or diarrhea over 2 daysSeek care; STEC can cause HUSCall a doctor; tell them it was raw milk
A raw milk product is recalledDispose of it, do not drink or feed itFollow the recall notice
Your state's rule is unclearAgency pages differ from advocacy listsCall the state agriculture or health department
A neighbor offers raw milk "from a licensed dairy"License is no guaranteeAsk what it is tested for and treat it as raw
H5N1 in your state's herdsDynamicCheck APHIS and your state veterinarian
Sources: CDC, California Department of Public Health and 4 more

Yogurt

Steps (Washington State, Alaska, Missouri and Utah State, ranges)

Materials: a heavy pot, accurate thermometer, clean jars, starter (plain yogurt with live cultures or a dried culture), an incubator (oven turned off, cooler with 110°F water, thermos or a heating pad on its lowest setting).

  1. Start with pasteurized milk, not UHT, and a clean pot.

  2. Heat to 180°F for 10 minutes (thinner) or 20 minutes (thicker) per Washington State; Alaska and Utah State say 185 to 200°F for 10 to 20 minutes.

  3. Cool to 108 to 112°F (WSU), 112 to 115°F (Alaska, Utah State) or 115°F (Missouri). A culture added above 115°F can die; yogurt bacteria "can be killed at temperatures above 130°F and will not grow well below 98°F".

  4. Add starter: 2 to 3 teaspoons per cup of milk (WSU), or 1/4 cup per quart and 1 cup per gallon (Alaska, Utah State).

  5. Incubate: 6 to 8 hours at 108 to 112°F (WSU), 4 to 7 hours at 110±5°F (Alaska), 4 to 8 hours at 100 to 110°F (Missouri) or 3 to 6 hours at 110°F (UC Davis). Yogurt sets near pH 4.6.

  6. Refrigerate as soon as it is firm.

How long it keeps and how much you get

Homemade yogurt keeps 10 to 21 days at or below 40°F (Washington State, Alaska), or "a week or longer" at 45°F or lower (UC Davis). Commercial yogurt is given 7 to 10 days (Kansas State) and 7 to 14 days (Georgia, 2011). One quart of milk makes 4 to 5 cups of yogurt; strained Greek-style yogurt drained 8 to 24 hours leaves about half to two-thirds of the volume. Frozen yogurt keeps 1 to 2 months and turns grainy. Starter upkeep differs: renew every 5 to 6 batches (WSU), re-culture at least weekly (Utah State), or use a fresh store culture each time (Alaska).

Diagram coming soonYogurt temperature ladder
Figure 6. Heat, cool, add starter, incubate, refrigerate.
Sources: Oregon State University Extension, University of Missouri Extension and 15 more

Kefir, cultured buttermilk and cultured cream

  • Milk kefir (Colorado State): pasteurized milk, not UHT, 18 to 24 hours at 65 to 85°F in the dark; check pH 4.0 to 4.5 if testing; drink or refrigerate up to 2 weeks. Utah State's kefir starter is incubated at about 110°F (43.3°C) and re-cultured at about 80°F (26.6°C).

  • Counter fermenting: Utah State says "NOT safe" and wants a water-bath incubator, a pH meter and pH 4.6 or less within 48 hours; Colorado State gives a counter window for kefir; an older UC Davis page uses a counter routine with no safety limits.

  • Cultured buttermilk (Utah State): packet culture in whole milk at about 108°F (42.3°C) for 18 to 48 hours to pH 4.6 or less; discard if not done in 48 hours.

  • Creme fraiche (Utah State): whipping cream heated to 185 to 200°F for 2 to 5 minutes, cooled to 104 to 113°F, cultured to pH 4.6 or less. A University of California volunteer handout uses 1 tablespoon whey or yogurt per cup of cream for 8 to 24 hours in a warm place with no temperature given.

  • Water kefir is not dairy. Milk grains and water grains are not interchangeable.

Sources: Colorado State University Extension, Utah State University Extension and 2 more

Butter

What butter is

Butter is made exclusively from milk or cream with or without salt and color and must have at least 80 percent milkfat by weight (21 U.S.C. 321a). It runs 80 to 82 percent fat, 16 to 17.5 percent water, about 1.5 percent salt and about 1 percent milk solids. Churning cream is 35 to 40 percent fat at pH 6.4 to 6.7, and cultured butter is pH 4.4 to 5.0.

Steps (UC Davis, 2017, home churning)

  1. Chill the cream below 45°F and age it 1 day.

  2. Churn at 52 to 60°F in summer or 58 to 66°F in winter for about 30 minutes, with the churn no more than half full. A commercial batch churn uses 30 to 33 percent fat cream at 9°C (summer) or 13°C (winter); the figures differ.

  3. Wash 2 to 3 times with cold water to avoid rancidity. Wash water colder than the butter firms it; warmer water softens it.

  4. Salt at 3/4 ounce per pound, work it in thoroughly, and freeze at 0°F for storage.

The pasteurizing question

The UC Davis home steps do not say to pasteurize the cream. Cream for graded butter is pasteurized at 165°F for 30 minutes or 185°F for 15 seconds, higher than the 145°F or 161°F fluid milk settings, and the federal table adds 5°F for products at 10 percent fat or more. No source tests whether 145°F for 30 minutes is enough for cream. A 2020 Belgian study found no Listeria growth in naturally contaminated raw-milk butter over its shelf life, but absence of growth is not safety, and Pennsylvania only began permitting raw milk butter in May 2026 with its own test limits.

Storage

Refrigerator: 1 to 3 months (Georgia, 2011), 1 to 2 months (Kansas State, 2026) or 2 weeks (Clemson, 2007). Freezer: 6 to 9 months from high-quality butter made from pasteurized cream; unsalted loses flavor sooner. Maine Extension (May 2026): salted butter in a covered dish below 70°F keeps 1 to 2 days on the counter; unsalted, cultured, whipped and compound butter go in the refrigerator; ghee is shelf-stable when sealed, with no time limit given. There is no Tier 1 shelf life for home-churned butter.

Diagram coming soonButter and the can
Figure 7. Why canning butter is unsafe.
Sources: Cornell University, University of Wisconsin-Madison Center for Dairy Research and 10 more

Simple cheeses

Yield and heat

About 10 pounds (1.25 gallons) of milk make 1 pound of cheese (New Mexico State). A 2022 lab model gave fresh-cheese yields of 15.4 percent of milk weight for cow, 11.9 percent goat and 22.9 percent ewe. If you start with raw milk, heat it to 145°F for 30 minutes, stirring, never below 145°F, then cool below 90°F (PNW 539); New Mexico State says 140 to 145°F, and the federal cheese standards deem pasteurized at 143°F for 30 minutes. Do not use ultra-pasteurized or UHT milk, which will not coagulate well. Boiling point falls about 2°F per 1,000 feet (about 196°F at 8,100 feet) but no source adjusted the 145°F hold.

Recipes in the sources

CheeseRecipe as printed
Queso blanco / paneer type1 gallon milk at 176°F for 20 minutes, 4.6 fluid ounces 5% vinegar plus 9.2 fluid ounces water until the curd mats
Ricotta1 quart 2% milk plus 4.5 teaspoons distilled vinegar heated to 185°F, rest 10 minutes, chill 40 minutes, drain 1 hour; yield 3/4 cup
Queso fresco1 quart cultured buttermilk, 2 quarts milk, 7 teaspoons white vinegar; set at 90°F; cut at 30–40 minutes; heat curds and whey to 115°F
MozzarellaHeat to 90°F; cut 1/2 inch; rise to 118°F over 45 minutes; stretch in 180°F water; brine in saturated salt (2 pounds per gallon) at 40–50°F for 24 hours
FetaBrine 2 cups salt per gallon for 2 months (Oregon State); or about 3.5% whey brine, 8 tablespoons per gallon at 150°F (NMSU)
Cottage, cream, Neufchatel (acid set)Set at 72–90°F once whey reaches titratable acidity 0.50–0.55 and pH 4.6–4.9; culture-only set 8–16 hours

Never heat rennet above 90°F or the curd will not form. Rennet: 1 teaspoon liquid equals 1 tablet, dissolved in cool distilled or boiled water just before use; calcium chloride firms homogenized-milk curd but is not used for mozzarella and not suited to aged Cheddar or Parmesan; the federal hard-cheese limit is 0.02 percent of milk weight. Queso fresco salt differs: 3/4 teaspoon (PNW 539) versus 2 teaspoons (NMSU) for the same amount of milk.

Shelf life

Soft cheese is over 45 percent water and keeps 5 to 7 days refrigerated (NMSU); PNW queso fresco keeps 1 week at 40°F or below or 1 month frozen; Neufchatel 7 to 10 days; mozzarella in water within 2 days; ricotta 2 weeks (Oregon State) versus 5 to 7 days (NMSU). Hard and semi-hard cheese freezes 6 months in blocks of 1 pound or less and 1 inch or less thick but turns crumbly; cream cheese, cottage cheese and ricotta freeze poorly. Hard cheese sealed in its package resists pathogens at room temperature far better than soft cheeses, and waxing is not a safe way to keep refrigerator-type cheese at room temperature (Utah State, 2009, outdated).

Sources: New Mexico State University Extension, Published research and 10 more

Aged cheese and the 60-day rule

What the law says

Under 21 CFR 133 (sections 133.113 and 133.182 re-read live on eCFR 2026-10-06), raw-milk Cheddar, Brick, Colby, washed-curd, Edam, granular-curd, hard, Limburger, provolone, soft-ripened, semisoft, spiced and Samsoe cheeses must be cured "at a temperature of not less than 35 °F for at least 60 days." Caciocavallo needs 90 days and Gorgonzola and Gruyere are at least 90 days old. Monterey Jack, mozzarella, cream cheese and the cottage cheese creaming mixture must be pasteurized, and part 133 has no unpasteurized cure for fresh cheeses. It is an interstate rule; the state decides intrastate sale.

What the evidence says

FDA's 2014 to 2016 sampling of 1,606 raw-milk cheeses aged 60 days found Salmonella 0.19 percent, Listeria 0.62 percent (0.89 percent in semi-soft), Shiga-toxin E. coli 0.68 percent (one pathogenic, 0.06 percent) and generic E. coli 5.4 percent; FDA said aging may not eliminate E. coli O157:H7 and Salmonella and Listeria may grow during aging. In raw-milk Cheddar E. coli O157:H7 fell less than 1 log at 60 days and less than 2 log at 120 days at 7°C; in a South Dakota study it was still detected in 25 g at 158 days. Salmonella added after aging survived 90 days at 4 or 10°C and 30 days at 21°C in Cheddar. A 2015 FDA and Health Canada model predicted that removing the 60-day rule would lower the risk of raw soft-ripened cheese by 1.5 to 2 times because aging lets Listeria grow. H5N1 survived cheese aging at pH 6.6 and 5.8 for 120 days but not at pH 5.0. Iowa State and UC Davis say 60 days does not guarantee safety while Penn State and UC Davis advise against raw milk for home cheese.

pH and moisture

The Wisconsin Center for Dairy Research puts the safety concern line at cheese pH above 5.6. Milk is pH 6.6 to 6.7, Cheddar about 5.1, milk above pH 6.8 suggests mastitis, and too much moisture raises water activity. Staphylococcus aureus grows from 7 to 47.8°C (about 45 to 118°F), its toxin survives heat, and 100,000 per gram can give a toxic dose.

Outbreak examples

The 2010 Bravo Farms Gouda E. coli O157:H7 outbreak sickened 38 people in five Western and Southwestern states, 15 hospitalized and 1 with HUS; the CDC page does not say the milk was raw. A 2026 outbreak of E. coli O26 linked to Graziers raw milk cheeses had 13 cases in 9 states, 8 hospitalizations and 3 HUS as of September 25, 2026, over half of those ill children 5 or younger.

Mold

On hard cheese cut off at least 1 inch around and below the spot. Discard soft cheese, shredded or sliced cheese, yogurt and sour cream with mold. Brie, Camembert and blue cheese are discarded if the mold is not the manufacturing mold. Do not sniff it.

Diagram coming soon60-day rule versus findings
Figure 8. The legal minimum next to what FDA sampling found.
Diagram coming soonMold decision
Figure 9. Hard cheese: cut 1 inch around mold. Soft cheese: discard.
Sources: Code of Federal Regulations (eCFR), Penn State Extension and 8 more

Common ferment and cheese mistakes

  1. Making yogurt, kefir or cheese from raw milk because the acid "kills everything".

  2. Fermenting on the counter without a controlled temperature or pH.

  3. Using ultra-pasteurized milk for cheese.

  4. Canning butter.

  5. Heating rennet above 90°F.

  6. Trusting the 60-day rule.

  7. Skipping the rinse after bleach.

  8. Leaving soft cheese or yogurt out for more than 2 hours.

  9. Feeding pregnant relatives fresh soft cheese.

Sources: Published research, University of Alaska Fairbanks Extension and 6 more

Troubleshooting yogurt, butter and cheese

ProblemLikely causeWhat to do
Yogurt stays thinCulture killed above 115°F, too cool, too shortCheck starter temperature and incubation (see ranges)
Yogurt stays runny after 8 hoursCool kitchen, weak starterUse a water bath or cooler; fresh starter
Yogurt or kefir smells off or shows moldContaminationDiscard; do not taste
Butter will not comeCream too cold or too warmChurn at 52–66°F depending on season
Butter goes rancidPoor washingWash 2 to 3 times in cold water
Curd will not formRennet heated above 90°F or old; UHT milkUse fresh rennet in cool water; do not use UHT milk
Curd too softHomogenized or heated milkCalcium chloride gives a firmer curd (not for mozzarella or aged Cheddar)
Cheese is too salty or blandRecipes differQueso fresco: 3/4 teaspoon vs 2 teaspoons
Mold on cheeseNormal on aged cheese; unsafe on softSee the mold rule above
Hard cheese turns crumbly after freezingNormalUse it for cooking
Sources: Oregon State University Extension, University of Alaska Fairbanks Extension and 8 more

Resources

By zone

Cold kitchens slow yogurt, hot barns stress animals and raise mastitis, and the raw milk rules change from state to state.

3–4
Wet teats can freeze in under a minute below minus 25°F wind chill; frostbite takes 45 to 60 days to heal; dry teats and keep the post-dip; a cold milkhouse doubles bleach contact time for every 18°F below 75°F. Cold-season milking and chilling; Alaska has a registration model; Montana, Wyoming and North Dakota are farm-sale states. A cold kitchen needs a water bath, cooler or heating pad for 108 to 112°F; warm cream to 58 to 66°F to churn in winter
5–6
Winter cooling is easy; a dry heavy-coated cow stays comfortable to below 18°F (Minnesota), Penn State says cold stress starts near 32°F; water at 40 to 65°F and frost-free. Northeast and upper Midwest license heavily; Minnesota summer peak of cases. Basements are cold enough to age cheese in winter only; 35°F or above for 60 days for raw milk cheese
7–8
Summer ice baths needed; mastitis season July to September. Southeast permits in SC and GA, bans in AL, VA, MD, FL, NC; heat and mastitis season. A warm kitchen incubates yogurt fast; a cooled space is needed for aging in summer
9–10
Heat stress; milk can fall up to 50 percent; water intake rises from about 30 to 45 gallons a day at 80°F; chilled water, shade and 10 to 15 minutes of drip-dry before milking. Heat and fast cooling; Arizona licensed, Texas licensed, Hawaii pasteurized only; no direct study of heat or flies on milk pathogens. Counter fermenting at 25°C only reached pH 5.0 in 24 hours; butter on the counter is a winter-only choice (an inference from the 70°F limit); a cooled aging space is needed most of the year
Northeast
Penn State dairy articles (routine, bleach, SCC); Vermont and Massachusetts cooling rules. VT, NH, ME, MA, CT, PA, NY allow forms of sale; RI and NJ do not; Pennsylvania May 2026 changes. Penn State cheesemaking and standards-of-identity pages; New Hampshire and Maine raw cheese rules
Southeast
Georgia heat-stress guidance; Virginia dairy cooling rule; South Carolina and Georgia raw milk standards. DE permit; SC and GA permit; WV legal with label; AR 2025 law; KY goat only; TN herd shares. Georgia and Clemson storage charts; heat in summer
Midwest
Ohio State home methods; South Dakota State and Ohio State winter teat article. IA, IL, MO limited sale; KS, NE, ND direct; SD license; OH, IN, MI bar; WI, MN restrict. Wisconsin Center for Dairy Research; Kansas State and Missouri storage pages; Wisconsin 61-day label
Southwest
No Southwest source found for this slice; New Mexico retail rule is 32 to 45°F within 2 hours. TX, NM, AZ permits; OK 2026 law. NMSU E-216 is the main home cheese guide; the 2010 Bravo Farms outbreak affected Arizona and New Mexico; no Arizona or Texas extension source
Pacific Northwest
Oregon State home method; Washington raw milk guide; Washington State milking practices. OR herdshare or small exception; WA licensed, shares are sales; Washington outbreaks. PNW 539 queso fresco; Oregon State feta and ricotta; Alaska yogurt method
Mountain West
Altitude lowers the boiling point about 2°F per 1,000 feet (about 196°F at 8,100 feet), so check thermometers in ice water; Montana small-dairy guide. ID shares and permit; MT small dairy; WY FFA; CO shares; NV certified; UT HB179. Utah State kefir, buttermilk and cream; Colorado State kefir; altitude does not change the pasteurizing hold

Where this comes from

Every fact in this lesson was checked against 186 published sources: 185 from extension services, the USDA and research journals and 1 from experienced growers and practitioners. Each section lists its own at the bottom.

See all 186 sources
CDC
U.S. Food and Drug Administration
Published research
Alaska DEC Office of the State Veterinarian
Colorado General Assembly, Office of Legislative Legal Services
Idaho State Department of Agriculture
Kentucky Legislative Research Commission
Maine Legislature, Office of the Revisor of Statutes
Minnesota Department of Agriculture
Montana Department of Public Health and Human Services
New Mexico State Records Center and Archives
New Mexico State University Extension
University of Alaska Fairbanks Extension
Washington State Department of Agriculture
Washington State Department of Agriculture, Food Safety Program

Summary

The whole lesson on one page. Print it or come back to it.

Key information

  • Pasteurize milk you drink unless you have read your state's rule and accepted the risk: 161°F for 15 seconds or 145°F for 30 minutes, held continuously, then chill to 40°F or below.
  • Cool fast. States that allow raw milk mostly require 40°F within 2 hours; commercial Grade A milk is cooled to 50°F within 4 hours and 45°F within 2 more.
  • Every public health agency read here advises against raw milk, and a license does not remove the risk. Children, pregnant women, people over 65 and people with weak immune systems are at greatest risk.
  • Raw milk law is a patchwork: farm sale, permits, herd or cow shares only, limits by animal or product, or prohibited. Confirm with your state agency.
  • Make yogurt, kefir and cheese from pasteurized milk. Do not ferment on the counter: dairy must reach pH 4.6 or less within 48 hours.
  • Never can butter. The 60-day aging rule for raw milk cheese is a legal minimum, not a safety guarantee.

Step by step

  1. 1.Milk from a clean, dry udder into a clean pail.
  2. 2.Cool right away in an ice bath, aiming for 40°F within 2 hours.
  3. 3.Stir constantly and hold 161°F for 15 seconds or 145°F for 30 minutes.
  4. 4.Chill in ice water to 40°F or below, then store at about 37°F toward the back of the refrigerator.
  5. 5.Wash the gear right after milking: rinse at 100 to 110°F, wash at 120 to 135°F for at least 5 minutes, post-rinse at 100 to 110°F, then an acid rinse.

Made it to the end? I’ll keep track for you on this device.