Skip to content
Goshen Exchange

PreservationLesson 4 of 7

Fermenting vegetables

Breakout About 13 min readNew to you

What you’ll learn

  • Why a ferment is safe: enough salt, no oxygen, and a pH of 4.6 or lower
  • The salt amounts for sauerkraut and fermented dill pickles, and why you never cut them
  • How to set up a crock or jar so the vegetables stay under the brine
  • How temperature changes the time, and what mold, scum and slime mean
  • Why garlic and herbs in oil are a different hazard, and what the rules are for selling ferments

The short version

  1. Sauerkraut takes 3 Tbsp of canning or pickling salt for every 5 lb of shredded cabbage. Don't cut it. The salt is part of what makes it safe.

  2. Keep the vegetables under the brine (1 to 2 inches), use only food-grade stone, glass or plastic containers, and ferment at about 68 to 75°F.

  3. If a ferment has fuzzy mold, slime or a rotten smell, throw it out. When in doubt, throw it out.

  4. The only home recipes USDA has tested for fermenting are sauerkraut and fermented dill pickles. Anything else is not a tested recipe.

What fermenting is, and why it's safe when done right

Fermenting uses lactic acid bacteria that are already on the vegetables. Salt draws sugar-rich juice out of the cells, the bacteria feed on it without oxygen and make acid, and the acid and salt hold back the organisms that spoil food or make people sick. You don't add a starter.

The stages in a kraut ferment: Leuconostoc bacteria start first and make carbon dioxide, so you see bubbling in the first day or two. After about a week, Lactobacillus plantarum takes over, and the finished kraut sits at about pH 3.5 (UW-Extension) or 3.2 to 3.4 (BC Centre for Disease Control). Cucumbers start near pH 6.5 and end at 3.1 to 3.5.

Diagram coming soonHow a ferment works
Figure 1. A ferment is safe when the pH falls below the 4.6 line.
Sources: UC Davis Dept. of Food Science and Technology / UC ANR, University of Illinois Extension and 8 more

Only two tested recipes

USDA's research-tested home recipes for fermented vegetables are sauerkraut and fermented dill pickles, according to Penn State and UNH Extension. UW-Extension adds that no tested recipes exist for long ferments of carrots, beets, greens and other vegetables, and fresh kimchi is acceptable only if the salted vegetables stand under 24 hours at room temperature. Lab work shows that vegetables with moderate or high sugar (peppers, tomatoes, green beans, sweet potato, corn) ferment incompletely. There is no Tier 1 home recipe for fermented hot sauce or fermented garlic.

Other extension pages publish wet-brine ratios for mixed vegetables: Kansas State gives 1 tsp salt per cup of water (2 tsp per cup for cucumbers and peppers) and the University of Minnesota gives 1 to 3 Tbsp per quart (up to 5 Tbsp for cucumbers, onions and radishes). Both label these as not USDA-tested. Treat them as the best available guidance, not a tested process.

Sources: Penn State Extension, University of New Hampshire Extension and 5 more

What you'll need

  • Canning or pickling salt. Pure salt with no iodine or anti-caking agent. Additives can cloud the brine and darken the product; Minnesota and BC's CDC go further and say they can interfere with fermentation. Oregon State's PNW 355 says table salt "may be used" but can cloud the brine. No source calls iodized salt dangerous.

  • A food-grade container: stone, glass or food-grade plastic. Not garbage bags or trash liners, and not copper, brass, iron, galvanized or aluminum. Old or glazed crocks can leach lead.

  • Size: 1 gallon of container for every 5 lb of vegetables, with 4 to 5 inches of space above the cabbage in a crock.

  • Something to hold the vegetables down: a plate that fits inside the crock topped with water-filled jars, or a double-bagged, brine-filled food-grade plastic bag. The brine for a bag is 4 1/2 Tbsp salt in 3 quarts of water (Penn State, NDSU, Virginia Tech) or 6 Tbsp in a gallon (UAF, CSU), so a leak doesn't dilute your ferment.

  • A cover: a clean towel, cheesecloth or coffee filter keeps out insects and dust.

  • A kitchen scale if you want to salt by weight, and a thermometer.

Diagram coming soonCrock setup
Figure 3. A crock set up with space at the top, weights, brine over the vegetables and a towel.
Sources: National Center for Home Food Preservation, University of Minnesota Extension and 9 more

Salt: the number that matters

WhatAmount
Sauerkraut, crock3 Tbsp canning salt per 5 lb shredded cabbage, mixed in 5-lb batches
By weightAbout 2 to 2.5% (CSU 2–2.5%; Clemson 2.25–2.5%; UW 2.25%; peer-reviewed optimum 2.0–2.25%)
Sauerkraut in jarsOregon State: 2 1/4 tsp salt per 1 1/4 lb cabbage (quart); Penn State: 3 1/2 Tbsp per 5 lb
Top-up brine1 1/2 Tbsp salt per quart water, boiled and cooled
Dill pickles, NCHFPper gallon of container: 4 lb pickling cucumbers, 1/2 cup salt, 1/4 cup 5% vinegar, 8 cups water

One USDA quirk: NCHFP's sauerkraut recipe is headed "25 lbs cabbage, 3/4 cup salt," but its steps say to add 3 Tbsp per 5-lb batch. Five batches is 15 Tbsp, not the 12 Tbsp in 3/4 cup. The page contradicts itself. This lesson follows the per-batch instruction: 3 Tbsp per 5 lb.

Salt by weight, not volume, if you can: 7 3/4 oz (220 g) of salt is 1 cup of canning salt, 1 1/2 cups of kosher salt, or about 3/4 cup plus 1 Tbsp of table salt. NCHFP and PNW 355 say not to use flake or kosher salt because their density varies; NMSU says to use 50% more kosher salt by volume.

Diagram coming soonSalt and cabbage
Figure 2. Three tablespoons of salt for each 5-lb batch of shredded cabbage.
Sources: National Center for Home Food Preservation, Penn State Extension and 6 more

Step by step: sauerkraut

  1. Pick firm, fresh cabbage and start within 24 to 48 hours of harvest. Late-season cabbage makes the best kraut.

  2. Work in 5-lb batches. Discard the outer leaves, quarter the heads, cut out the cores, and shred to about the thickness of a quarter. Don't grind it.

  3. Add 3 Tbsp canning salt per batch and mix with clean hands. Pack firmly until the salt draws out juice. Repeat until the container is full.

  4. Keep it under. The juice should rise above the cabbage. If it doesn't, add boiled and cooled brine (1 1/2 Tbsp salt per quart of water). Add a plate and weights, or a brine-filled bag, and cover with a clean towel.

  5. Hold it at 68 to 75°F. Kraut is fully fermented in about 3 to 4 weeks at 70 to 75°F and takes about 5 to 6 weeks at 60 to 65°F. Below 60°F it may not ferment, and above 75°F it may turn soft. Penn State says above 80°F kraut softens and spoils.

  6. Check it often. Skim any white scum, keep the cabbage under the brine, and look at the surface for mold.

  7. When the bubbling stops, taste it. With a brine bag, fermentation is over when bubbling stops (Penn State). Minnesota says it's ready at pH 4.6 or lower with bubbling stopped; if not, keep fermenting and recheck every 1 to 2 days.

  8. Refrigerate it or can it. Left at room temperature it keeps souring and ripens "beyond palatability and safety" (Kansas and Missouri extension).

Small batches in jars: a 5-lb batch makes about two quarts or one half-gallon. Use a lid that vents (a one-way valve lid or an airlock) or burp the jar to let gas out. A fully airtight jar can break.

Sources: National Center for Home Food Preservation, Penn State Extension and 13 more

Temperature and time

TemperatureWhat happens
70 to 75°FKraut done in about 3 to 4 weeks
68 to 72°FColorado State: 7 to 14 days for a small batch; Virginia Tech says this is best
60 to 70°FClemson and Kansas State: best quality, slower, less acid
60 to 65°FAbout 5 to 6 weeks
Below 60°FMay not ferment
Above 75 to 80°FSoft, spoiled

Sources disagree on the ideal range and on where softening starts: 70–75°F, 68–72°F, 60–70°F or about 64°F for the best flavor, and 75°F, 78°F or 80°F for the upper limit. Cooler fermenting makes better food but takes longer; hot weather is the main risk.

  • Cold kitchens (zones 3 to 5 in winter): warm the container. Below 60°F kraut may not ferment.

  • Hot kitchens (zones 8 to 10 in summer): move it to a cool room, check it often, or ferment in fall and spring. For kimchi in hot weather, NC State and Colorado State suggest the refrigerator, taking 3 to 4 days.

Diagram coming soonTemperature strip
Figure 4. The working range for a kraut ferment.
Sources: National Center for Home Food Preservation, University of Alaska Fairbanks Extension and 9 more

Fermented dill pickles

NCHFP's recipe uses, per gallon of container, 4 lb of 4-inch pickling cucumbers, 2 Tbsp dill seed or 4 to 5 heads of dill, 1/2 cup salt, 1/4 cup 5% vinegar and 8 cups water. Pour the brine over the cucumbers, weight them under the brine, and hold at 70 to 75°F for about 3 to 4 weeks (or 55 to 65°F for 5 to 6 weeks). Above 80°F pickles soften.

Cucumber prep: use pickling varieties (not waxed or slicing cucumbers), start within 24 hours of harvest, and cut a 1/16-inch slice off the blossom end, because an enzyme there softens pickles.

Sources: National Center for Home Food Preservation, Penn State Extension and 2 more

Kimchi

Kimchi is a refrigerator food more than a shelf food. Colorado State's method ferments it 1 to 2 days at about 68°F, or 3 to 4 days in the refrigerator, until a pH test strip reads 4.6 or lower, then stores it refrigerated and eats it within 2 weeks. Final salt is 2 to 5% (CSU) or 3 to 6% after a pre-brine (peer-reviewed review). In lab tests, E. coli O157:H7, Salmonella and Listeria all survived in kimchi held at 50°F for 7 days, and BC's CDC notes kimchi has been linked to E. coli outbreaks. No Tier 1 source gives a tested home salt-by-weight protocol for kimchi.

Sources: Colorado State University Extension, Oregon State University Extension and 4 more

Signs something is wrong

What you seeWhat it meansWhat to do
White, flat film, not fuzzy or roundKahm yeast: common and safe (Illinois)Skim it off; UC Davis says to remove it from kraut regularly
Fuzzy or colored growth (green, blue, brown, black)MoldDiscard the ferment (UC Davis, Penn State, NDSU)
Slime, or a putrid or rotten smellSpoilageDiscard
Soft or slippery picklesToo little salt or acid, blossom ends, or impure saltDiscard if spoilage is evident
Pink or dark krautYeast or spoilage organisms in air or uncovered cabbageDiscard if slimy; sources disagree on plain pink kraut
Hollow pickles (bloaters)Yeast and low saltDon't count on them keeping

A rotten smell in the first week is normal for kraut, but it shouldn't persist. Some extension pages say small patches of mold or scum can be skimmed and the rest kept; this lesson follows the stricter rule.

Diagram coming soonWhat's on the surface
Figure 5. Skim kahm yeast; discard anything fuzzy or slimy.
Sources: University of Illinois Extension, UC Davis Dept. of Food Science and Technology / UC ANR and 8 more

Storing finished ferments

  • Refrigerator: kraut keeps several months; fermented pickles keep 4 to 6 months in the original container if you remove scum and mold; Minnesota says up to 9 months. A 2% salted ferment can keep at least 3 months in a root cellar if submerged, but refrigeration is recommended.

  • Freezer: sauerkraut freezes fine; pickles lose texture.

  • Canning: heat from canning kills the live bacteria, but the kraut stays safe. Don't can or pasteurize a ferment before it tastes tart. USDA hot-pack times for kraut are 10 minutes (pints) and 15 (quarts) at 0 to 1,000 ft, up to 20 and 25 minutes above 6,000 ft; find your altitude band in the canning lesson.

Sources: National Center for Home Food Preservation, University of Minnesota Extension and 5 more

Garlic and herbs in oil: a different hazard

The documented botulism events tied to "fermented" foods in the CDC records read here were low-salt or low-acid protein ferments (home-fermented tofu, a salt-cured fish called fesikh), not salted lactic-acid vegetable ferments. A pickled-egg outbreak in Illinois had a brine pH of 3.5 while the egg yolk's interior hadn't been acidified.

Diagram coming soonOil danger
Figure 6. Garlic in oil is a refrigerator food with a short clock.
Sources: Nummer, Oregon State University Extension and 2 more

Testing pH at home

pH 4.6 is the botulism line. UC Davis says to check a ferment's pH periodically but names no device; Colorado State uses a strip for kimchi. Strips are limited: UW-Madison says they work only if the product's pH is below 4.0 and a meter is needed above that; Wisconsin allows short-range strips only if the product normally reads 4.0 or lower; Pennsylvania requires a calibrated meter above 4.0. A meter should read to at least 0.02 pH and be calibrated with pH 4.0 and 7.0 buffers each day you use it. These rules come from small-business guidance, and no Tier 1 source gives a home-ferment strip protocol.

Sources: UC Davis Dept. of Food Science and Technology / UC ANR, Colorado State University Extension and 3 more

Other home ferments

  • Kombucha: Colorado State says the pH should drop from about 5 to 4.2 within 7 days and keep falling toward about 2.5; if it doesn't, suspect a bad culture or a too-cool room. Discard the SCOBY and liquid if there's any fuzzy mold. Home batches can pass 0.5% alcohol, which makes kombucha a regulated alcoholic drink. No outbreak has been tied to kombucha, though 1995 illnesses in Iowa were never explained.

  • Sourdough starter: it acidifies below pH 4.6. Discard it if there's any colored or fuzzy mold; liquid on top and whitish clumps on a refrigerated starter are safe.

  • Dairy ferments (yogurt, kefir, cheese) are covered in the dairy and cheese lesson.

Sources: Colorado State University Extension, University of California Agriculture and Natural Resources

Selling ferments (checked 2026-10-04)

Federal rules treat a "naturally fermented" product (brined, fermented a week or more, reaching pH 4.6 or lower without added acid) differently from an acidified food, but that's an inspector's definition. Home sellers follow state rules. A summary:

  • Allowed with limits: Wisconsin (Pickle Bill, $5,000 a year, farmers markets only), Texas (approved recipe or pH test, batch records, cap $150,000), Minnesota (pH 4.6 or lower, $78,000 cap), Colorado (pH 4.6 or below, free pH testing), Oregon (Farm Direct, lacto-fermented only), North Carolina (shelf-stable acidified pickles with a process letter), Pennsylvania (lab pH test and registration).

  • Not allowed as cottage foods: Washington, California, Florida, New York home processors.

  • Unclear or unconfirmed: Utah and Arizona.

Confirm with your state agency before you sell anything.

Sources: U.S. Food and Drug Administration, Code of Federal Regulations (eCFR) and 13 more

Materials and costs

ItemAboutNotes
Canning or pickling saltno Tier 1 price—
Food-grade crock or jarsno Tier 1 price—
pH meterno Tier 1 priceNeeds ±0.02 accuracy and pH 4.0 and 7.0 buffers
Sources: University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Food Science

Common mistakes

  1. Cutting the salt in kraut or pickles.

  2. Letting vegetables float above the brine.

  3. Sealing a ferment airtight.

  4. Making up a ferment recipe for other vegetables as if it were tested.

  5. Skimming mold and eating the rest when in doubt.

Sources: USDA Agricultural Research Service, Oregon State University Extension and 7 more

Troubleshooting

What you seeLikely causeWhat to do
Soft kraut or picklesToo warm, too little salt, uneven salting, air pocketsDiscard if slimy; ferment cooler and use the full salt
Cloudy brine or sedimentIodized or additive saltUse canning salt
Dark krautIodized salt, air exposure, high temperatureKeep under brine; use canning salt
No bubblingCold room, or cabbage not saltedCheck temperature; a cold ferment is slow
Sources: Virginia Cooperative Extension, Oregon State University Extension and 4 more

Resources

By zone

Your kitchen temperature is what changes a ferment: cold winter kitchens slow it down and hot summer kitchens spoil it. Here is what shifts by zone.

3–4
Winter kitchens may be too cool for kraut; warm the container.
5–6
68 to 75°F is the working range for ferments.
7–8
Summer kitchens pass 75 to 80°F; ferment in fall and spring.
9–10
Hot kitchens exceed the working range in summer; refrigerator kimchi in hot weather.

Where this comes from

Every fact in this lesson was checked against 66 published sources, all from extension services, the USDA and research journals. Each section lists its own at the bottom.

See all 66 sources
University of Illinois Extension
Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment
North Carolina Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services
South Dakota State University Extension
University of California Agriculture and Natural Resources
University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Food Science
Virginia Cooperative Extension
Wisconsin DATCP, Division of Food and Recreational Safety
Wisconsin Department of Agriculture, Trade and Consumer Protection

Summary

The whole lesson on one page. Print it or come back to it.

Key information

  • Sauerkraut takes 3 Tbsp of canning or pickling salt for every 5 lb of shredded cabbage. Never reduce the salt.
  • Keep the vegetables 1 to 2 inches under the brine in a stone, glass or food-grade plastic container.
  • Ferment at 68 to 75°F. Below 60°F kraut may not ferment, and above 75°F it may turn soft.
  • A ferment is safe at pH 4.6 or lower, because botulism bacteria can't grow below it.
  • Only two home ferments are USDA-tested: sauerkraut and fermented dill pickles.
  • Fuzzy or colored mold, slime or a rotten smell means throw it out. Garlic or herbs in oil: refrigerate and use within 4 days, or freeze.

Step by step

  1. 1.Shred. Use firm, fresh cabbage in 5-lb batches.
  2. 2.Salt. Mix in 3 Tbsp canning salt per batch and pack until the juice rises.
  3. 3.Weight. Keep the cabbage under the brine and cover it with a clean towel.
  4. 4.Hold. Keep it at 68 to 75°F and check often, skimming any scum.
  5. 5.Finish. When the bubbling stops, taste it, then refrigerate or can it.

Made it to the end? I’ll keep track for you on this device.