Skip to content
Goshen Exchange

SustainabilityLesson 4 of 7

Manure management

Breakout About 21 min readNew to you

What you’ll learn

  • The 120-day and 90-day waiting periods between raw manure and harvest
  • Why poultry manure is hot-composted to 131°F instead of waited out
  • Why an old pile isn't composted manure, and which manures never go on food crops
  • How to test manure and set a rate by soil test, not by the truckload
  • Where to keep a pile so it stays out of your well, and the state rules to look up

The short version

  1. Raw manure goes on in fall, on soil, never on growing crops. Leave at least 120 days before harvesting anything that touches the soil and 90 days for crops held off the ground. That is the USDA organic rule, and FDA calls it "prudent." FDA has set no number of its own and has proposed none as of October 2026.

  2. For poultry manure, compost it instead of waiting it out. In FDA's 2026 model, Salmonella from raw poultry manure stayed higher than in compost-treated fields even at 120 days. It took about 600 days to fall below the same-day compost level.

  3. No manure gets a pass. Rabbit, goat, sheep, horse and llama manure are all raw manure for food safety. Never use dog, cat, pig or human manure on food gardens.

  4. A pile of old manure isn't composted manure. On organic farms, manure aged 6–12 months tested positive for pathogens more often than manure aged 2–6 months.

  5. Store it covered and away from water. Keep piles at least 150–200 ft from your well and 100 ft or more from streams, out of the floodplain, with roof water diverted away. A tarp cuts nitrogen loss from about 31% to about 10% over four months.

  6. Rate it by a soil test, not by the truckload. Manure brings more phosphorus than plants need compared with nitrogen. Year after year that builds up. A manure test costs about $15–$81.

  7. Learn your state's rules. Pennsylvania requires a written plan for every farm that spreads manure, even with one horse. Maryland and Vermont ban winter spreading for all farm sizes. Federal CAFO rules almost never reach a homestead.

Food safety: the rules that matter most

What FDA's 2026 risk assessment found

FDA modeled lettuce grown with raw manure in three regions, comparing each wait with harvesting right after spreading:

  • Cattle manure, E. coli O157: a 120-day wait cut predicted levels about 200- to 2,600-fold in the West, about 80-fold in the Mid-Atlantic and 20- to 45-fold in the South. Predicted illness fell 463- to 1,243-fold in the West, 62- to 72-fold in the Mid-Atlantic and 21- to 45-fold in the South.

  • Poultry manure, Salmonella: a 120-day wait cut levels about 30- to 300-fold. But they stayed above the levels predicted for compost-treated fields at every wait from 45 to 120 days. The model needed about 600 days to beat compost spread on harvest day.

  • FDA proposed no interval with the assessment.

What farm studies found

  • Raw manure carries pathogens often. On 19 organic farms in four states, at least one pathogen turned up in 24.5% of cattle-manure samples, 18.4% of sheep and goat samples, about 16% of poultry samples and 2% of horse samples.

  • Aged isn't safe. Pathogen rates by age were 29% under 2 months, 10% at 2–6 months, 32% at 6–12 months and 7% over a year. Commercial compost was 5%.

  • It can last past 90 days. In Mid-Atlantic field trials, E. coli outlasted 90 days in 61% of poultry-litter plots and 50% of horse-manure plots. In one fall trial it lasted at least 169 days.

  • Cold slows die-off. Bacteria survive much longer in soil at 32–50°F than above 68°F.

  • Clean-looking counts can mislead. After goats and sheep grazed test plots, ordinary E. coli fell back to normal in 87–147 days. Shiga-toxin E. coli was still in the soil at 115–147 days.

  • The rule works most of the time. Farms following 90/120 days rarely had pathogens on produce: 2 of 527 samples, both Listeria. That's why the interval is a minimum, not a guarantee.

Manure by animal: what to do with it

ManureFood-garden useWhy
Chicken, turkey, duckHot-compost it (131°F for 3 days throughout). If you use it raw, keep the 120/90-day minimum and keep it off ground for salad and root crops: in FDA's model, waiting didn't match compost for well over a yearFDA's poultry Salmonella results; very salty fresh, so wait 3–4 weeks before planting
Cattle, horseCompost, or raw in fall with 120/90 days—
Goat, sheepSame as cattle. Treat as raw42.5% of Minnesota goat droppings and 41.7% of California sheep droppings carried Shiga-toxin E. coli after grazing
RabbitSame as cattle. "Cold manure" means it won't burn plants, not that it's germ-freeRabbits carry disease-causing E. coli; no rule makes an exception
Llama, alpacaCompost before vegetablesNo pathogen data exist
PigNot on food gardensExtension consensus; worm eggs persist in soil for years
Dog, cat, humanNever on food crops. Don't compost cat waste—

Teas and side-dressing

  • Raw manure tea and compost leachate count as raw manure. Put them on soil only, with the 90/120-day wait. Spraying them on leaves is prohibited under organic guidance.

  • Compost tea: use drinkable water, clean equipment and finished compost. Never use it on sprouts.

  • Don't add molasses. It lets E. coli and Salmonella regrow at 0.5% or more. Tea from composted chicken manure grew 100 times more Salmonella than tea from composted dairy manure.

  • Never side-dress growing crops with raw manure.

Residues to know about

  • Persistent weed killers:

    • The Milestone and GrazonNext labels (aminopyralid) bar manure from animals that ate treated hay or forage within the previous 3 days from compost and mulch, and from land for broadleaf crops.
    • Treated hay and straw stays out of compost for 18 months.
    • Before planting broadleaf crops on land that got such manure, a field bioassay must show the crop grows normally.
    • Test outside manure with the pea pot test in the Composting lesson.
  • Dewormers:

    • Ivermectin-family drugs pass into manure.
    • In sheep droppings on pasture, half broke down in about 23–27 days.
    • Hot composting removed only about 39% in 21 days. Composting doesn't reliably clear them.
  • Antibiotic resistance:

    • Fresh manure raises resistant bacteria in soil, and some resistance genes showed up only on vegetables sown right after manuring.
    • It took about a year to fade in an Ontario study.
  • Metals:

    • Pig and poultry feeds carry extra copper and zinc, which builds up in topsoil after years of heavy manure, especially at old pile sites.
    • Liming to pH 6.5–6.8 reduces the harm.
  • Arsenic feed drugs for poultry were withdrawn in 2013–2016. Current US litter shouldn't carry them.

Hands, tools and produce

  • Wash hands with soap and water for 20 seconds after handling manure. Hand sanitizer works poorly on dirty hands and against germs like Cryptosporidium.

  • Wear gloves and closed-toe shoes for manure work.

  • Clean tools with 1 tablespoon of bleach per gallon of water.

  • Rinse produce under running water, rubbing it. Brush firm produce. Don't use soap. Washing reduces contamination but doesn't make manure-contaminated produce safe.

  • Keep pets and farm animals out of the vegetable garden.

  • Who should skip raw produce: pregnant women, older adults, young children and the chronically ill should not eat uncooked produce from a garden given raw manure that season.

Do the federal produce rules apply to you?

  • Not covered: produce grown for your own household or farm.

  • Not covered: farms averaging $34,324 or less a year in produce sales over 2023–2025. That's FDA's inflation-adjusted $25,000 figure, updated each year. Bartered produce counts as sales.

  • Not covered: crops on FDA's "rarely consumed raw" list, including potatoes, sweet potatoes, winter squash, pumpkins, sweet corn, collards, asparagus, garden beets, eggplant, okra and dry beans.

  • Qualified exemption: for farms under $686,476 in total food sales that sell mostly to consumers and nearby stores and restaurants. They still have labeling and record duties.

  • Not being covered doesn't protect you if your produce makes someone sick.

Diagram coming soonManure-to-harvest countdown
Figure 1. Count the days from manure to harvest, not to planting.
Diagram coming soonManure by animal decision chart
Figure 2. What to do with each animal's manure.
Diagram coming soonAged is not composted
Figure 3. A pile aged 6 to 12 months is no safer than fresh.
Diagram coming soonResidue warning card
Figure 12. Three residues to know about: weed killers, dewormers and feed metals.
Sources: Code of Federal Regulations (eCFR), U.S. Food and Drug Administration and 11 more

What your animals make

How much

Animal (size)Manure per day, as excreted
Horse, 1,000 lb, idle54.5 lb
Pig, 150 lb, finishing7.4 lb
Goat, 80 lb (160 lb)4.2 lb (8.4 lb)
Lamb, 100 lb4.1 lb
Meat rabbit, 11 lb1.65 lb
Duck, 4 lb0.44 lb
Broiler, 4 lb0.38 lb
Laying hen, 4 lb0.20 lb
Turkey hen, 10 lb0.47 lb
  • Bedding and wasted feed often double the volume you handle. One horse makes about 9.1 tons of manure a year. Two horses kept in a corral on 10 lb of straw a day each come to about 23.5 tons a year.

  • By volume, a horse makes about 0.75–1.0 cu ft of manure a day before bedding. Soiled bedding adds 0.6–1.6 cu ft more, and up to 3–4 cu ft with heavy shavings.

  • Llamas, alpacas, goats and sheep: Maryland plans on about 40 lb per 1,000 lb of animal a day. Rabbit and camelid figures rest on very few samples, so treat them as rough.

What's in it

Book values, lb per ton, as is (fresh, with typical bedding). Your manure can differ from these by 100% or more:

ManureN (lb/ton)P₂O₅ (lb/ton)K₂O (lb/ton)C:N
Broiler litter46–7353–5536–476–24
Turkey~40~50~3016 (litter)
Laying hen34–37~51~264–18
Duck~17~21~30no figure in our sources
Sheep18–23~8~2016
Beef11–12~7~1019
Dairy, solid~10~4~820
Horse9–124.5–5~930
Pig———12–21 (pig manure is not for food gardens)

P₂O₅ and K₂O are oxide values; some tables (like PNW0533) print elemental P and K, which you multiply by 2.29 and 1.2 to compare. For the percent-based Utah State lab averages, including rabbit and goat, see the Composting lesson.

  • Southeast broiler litter averages about 63-55-47 lb per ton (UGA lab), roughly a 3-3-2 fertilizer. It also works as a weak lime, about a tenth as strong as agricultural limestone.

  • Bedding changes everything. Wheat straw runs about 80:1 carbon to nitrogen, sawdust 200–750:1, and wood chips about 640:1. Manure over about 25:1, or under about 1% N, takes nitrogen from the soil for several weeks after you spread it. Horse manure on shavings is the usual example.

How much nitrogen plants actually get

Only part of manure's nitrogen feeds plants the first season. Pacific Northwest extension estimates, as a share of total N:

ManureAvailable in season one
Broiler or laying-hen40–70%
Sheep25–50%
Beef, dairy, rabbit20–40%
Horse, or heavily wood-bedded manure0–20%

Ammonia escapes into the air while manure sits on top of the ground:

  • Minnesota: beef manure gives 60% of its N if worked in within 12 hours, 45% at 12–96 hours and 25% after that.

  • UMass: about 20% of the ammonia is lost if worked in within 1 day, 50% within 2 days and up to 80% within 5 days.

  • Weather matters most. Left on bare soil, about 40% of the ammonium is lost in cool, wet weather and up to 90% in warm, dry weather.

  • Rain does the work. Half an inch of soaking rain or sprinkler water moves ammonium in about as well as tillage, if the soil isn't already soaked.

  • Solid manure is mostly organic N, so racing to till it in gains little. Dry poultry litter is only about 15% ammonium. Liquid swine and dairy manure (50–65% ammonium) gain the most from quick incorporation.

Later years: manure keeps releasing a little nitrogen. Oregon State uses about 15% of what's left in year 2, 7% in year 3 and 3% in year 4. Georgia expects very little carryover from litter in its hot, humid climate. Sources disagree here, so soil-test rather than lean on carryover credits.

Phosphorus and potassium are mostly available in year one: about 70–90% of the P and 80–100% of the K.

Compost gives up only about 10–15% of its N in year one. Composting can lose up to 40% of the N, but it cuts the volume by half or more.

Diagram coming soonFirst-year N by manure
Figure 4. How much nitrogen each manure gives in its first season.
Diagram coming soonWhere manure nitrogen goes
Figure 11. Where manure nitrogen goes: gas, year-one release, and the slow tail.
Sources: Utah State University Extension, USDA NRCS and 14 more

Test it

Taking a sample (solid manure)

  1. Take 10–25 small scoops from many depths around the pile. Skip the crust and the rain-washed outside.

  2. Mix them in a clean plastic bucket, not metal.

  3. Fill a quart freezer bag, double-bag it, label it, and freeze it.

  4. Ship it early in the week so it doesn't sit in a warehouse over the weekend.

  5. Sample before spreading season so the results come back in time.

What to ask for

  • Total N, ammonium-N, P, K and moisture (dry matter), reported "as is."

  • Add salts (EC) in dry regions.

  • Add C:N for bedded or composted manure.

How often: test every year for about 3 years to learn your average. After that, test every 3–4 years, or whenever feed, bedding or storage changes.

Reading the report

  • Percent × 20 = lb per ton. ppm × 0.002 = lb per ton.

  • P × 2.29 = P₂O₅. K × 1.2 = K₂O.

  • Organic N = total N − ammonium-N.

  • Check the basis. Dry-basis value × (% solids ÷ 100) = as-is value. Some labs report N and P on different bases. NC's lab, for one, reports N "as is" but P and K dry.

What it costs (prices checked 2026-10-01)

LabPrice
NC Dept. of Agriculture$15 in state, $25 out of state (+$15 for ammonium and nitrate)
University of Wisconsin$33 (+$8 for ammonium)
University of Vermont$45
Oregon State$81 + $7 prep, 6–8 weeks
Delaware Dept. of AgricultureFree for Delaware residents
Diagram coming soonSampling a pile
Figure 5. Take 10 to 25 scoops from many depths, not just the surface.
Sources: University of Minnesota Extension, University of Delaware Extension and 6 more

How much to spread

The formula

Tons per acre = crop N need ÷ (lb N per ton × share available)

Worked example (Pacific NW extension): sweet corn needs 100 lb of N. Beef manure has 11 lb N per ton, 25% available, so each ton gives 2.75 lb.

  • 100 ÷ 2.75 = about 36 tons per acre.

  • That much manure also brings about 184 lb of P₂O₅ and 362 lb of K₂O, far more than the corn uses.

That's the catch with rating manure by nitrogen.

  • It builds up phosphorus. Year after year, nitrogen-based rates pile up soil phosphorus.

  • High-P soils: set the rate by P and make up the nitrogen another way.

  • When more P stops helping: Minnesota sees no yield gain above 21 ppm Bray P (16 ppm Olsen). It says to stop applying manure above 50 ppm Bray (30 ppm Olsen), especially near water.

  • A good middle path: supply only 50–70% of the crop's N from manure and side-dress the rest if the crop needs it.

Gardens (per 100 sq ft)

University of Wisconsin rates, each supplying about 0.2 lb of plant-available N. A 5-gallon bucket holds about 25 lb:

ManureRaw, no beddingRaw, with beddingComposted
Poultry20 lb (about 1 bucket)30 lb70 lb
Dairy75 lb95 lb200 lb
Sheep40 lb50 lb—
Horse—65 lb—
  • Upper limits per year (University of Arizona), lb per sq ft: dairy or beef 1, horse 1¼, sheep ⅔, chicken ⅓.

  • Scale conversion: 1 ton per acre is about 46 lb per 1,000 sq ft (2,000 ÷ 43.56).

  • Worked example: a 1,000 sq ft garden at Wisconsin's rate for poultry manure with bedding takes 300 lb, about 12 buckets. Use about 28 buckets if it's composted. Arithmetic from the UW rates.

Pasture and hay

  • A low-input grass hayfield making 3 tons of dry matter an acre removes about 96 lb N per acre a year (Oregon State).

  • Each ton of grass hay carries off about 8.9 lb P₂O₅ (Minnesota).

  • Worked example (our arithmetic): 3 tons of grass hay an acre carries off about 27 lb P₂O₅ (3 × 8.9). One horse's manure holds about 40 lb P₂O₅ a year, so two horses make about 80 lb. That replaces the phosphorus on roughly 3 acres of hayfield, about 6 tons of manure per acre (2 × 9.1 tons ÷ 3).

  • Southeast broiler litter (UGA):

GrassLitter per acre
Tall fescue or orchardgrass pasture1–3 tons (split early fall and early spring)
Fescue-clover1 ton
Common bermuda or bahia pasture1–3 tons
Hybrid bermudagrass pasture3–5 tons (split early spring and midsummer)
Bermudagrass hay3–6 tons

Calibrate your spreader (tarp method)

  1. Lay three tarps of known size (for example 6 × 6 ft) across the spreading path.

  2. Spread at your normal gear and speed.

  3. Weigh the manure on each tarp. Weigh a bucket empty and with the tarp's load, then subtract.

  4. Pounds ÷ tarp sq ft × 21.8 = tons per acre. Example: 20 lb on a 6 × 6 ft tarp is about 12 tons per acre.

  5. Repeat and average.

  • Weight from volume: solid manure weighs about 55 lb per cu ft. To check yours, weigh a full 5-gallon bucket several times, average, and multiply by 1.5 for lb per cu ft.

  • No spreader? A wheelbarrow and fork, buckets or a pickup bed work for small amounts. An ATV-pulled ground-driven spreader is the next step up.

Diagram coming soonThe phosphorus trap
Figure 6. Rating by nitrogen lets soil phosphorus climb year after year.
Diagram coming soonGarden bucket math
Figure 7. The same nitrogen takes very different amounts of each manure.
Diagram coming soonTarp calibration
Figure 13. Calibrating a spreader with three tarps and a scale.
Diagram coming soonHayfield nutrient loop
Figure 14. Two horses' manure and the hayfield acres that balance it.
Sources: Pacific Northwest Extension, Penn State College of Agricultural Sciences Cooperative Extension and 8 more

Storing manure

Pick the site

  • Wells: follow your state's number. Where none applies, keep 150–200 ft away and downhill of the well. Published setbacks range from 50 to 200 ft.

  • Streams, ponds, ditches: at least 100 ft (Pennsylvania, Maryland, Delaware). Vermont requires 200 ft.

  • Property lines and neighbors: 35–100 ft from the line and 150–200 ft from a neighbor's house is typical.

  • Groundwater: keep the base at least 2 ft above the seasonal high water table.

  • Flooding: stay out of the 100-year floodplain.

  • Slope: choose flat ground. Pennsylvania field stacks need under 8% slope; Minnesota bars piles on slopes over 6%.

Keep clean water clean

  • Put gutters and downspouts on barns so roof water never runs through manure.

  • Berm or ditch around the pile so uphill runoff goes around it.

  • Leave a grass filter strip downhill of the pile.

Choose a setup

From most to least protective:

  1. Roofed three-wall bunker on concrete. Best for wet climates and small lots.

  2. Covered or tarped pile on concrete or packed stone dust.

  3. Uncovered pad with a grass filter strip downhill.

  4. Hauler's dumpster. Empty it weekly in fly season and set it on a pad to catch drips.

Size it

  • Size for the longest stretch you can't spread: about 180 days in cold zones and 120–180 days in the Southeast.

  • One stalled horse needs about 280–430 cu ft for 6 months (10–16 cu yd).

  • A three-sided bin holds much more per square foot than a free-standing pile.

Cover it

  • Nitrogen: an uncovered pile of cattle manure lost about 31% of its nitrogen (and 59% of its carbon) in 130 days. A covered pile lost about 10%.

  • P and K: these mostly stay in covered manure, but rain washes 20–40% of the P and 30–50% of the K out of open lots.

  • Composting lost more nitrogen (46%) than plain stockpiling. It trades nitrogen for less volume and fewer weed seeds, fly eggs and germs.

Flies

  • Flies breed in manure from about 65°F to the first killing frost, and eggs can become flies in 7 days.

  • Remove, spread thin, or dry manure below about 50% moisture every week in fly season.

  • Spread or haul winter piles before it warms up.

Diagram coming soonStorage site map
Figure 8. Where the pile goes: flat, downhill of the well, with clean water routed around it.
Diagram coming soonPile cross-section
Figure 9. Uncovered and tarped piles side by side.
Diagram coming soonStorage options ladder
Figure 15. Four ways to store manure, from best to least protective.
Diagram coming soonFly cycle
Figure 16. Flies go from egg to adult in 7 days in warm, wet manure.
Sources: Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection, Maryland Department of Agriculture and 10 more

When to spread

  • Food gardens: raw manure in fall. Work it in, then sow a cover crop. Maine says sow the cover crop by October 1. Use compost that met the heat standard in spring.

  • Fields and pastures, for nutrients: spring is best, because fall manure on bare ground loses nitrogen over a wet winter. West of the Cascades, pastures can take moderate rates from late February to mid-October. This conflicts with the food-safety advice above. On food ground, safety wins.

  • Never on frozen, snow-covered or saturated ground. Don't spread when a storm is forecast within 24 hours.

  • In heat: spread before a half-inch rain, or work it in the same day, to keep the nitrogen.

Sources: University of Wisconsin Extension, University of Maine Extension and 5 more

The rules (checked 2026-10-01)

Federal:

  • A homestead is almost never a CAFO. A feeding operation means animals confined 45 days or more a year where nothing grows. Grazing pasture doesn't count.

  • The thresholds are high. Large CAFOs start at 500 horses or 1,000 cattle. Medium ones (150+ horses, 300+ cattle) count only if they discharge to water.

  • Composting doesn't change the category. Manure piles and compost piles count as part of a regulated operation.

States are what reach small farms. Some apply regardless of size:

StateWhat a small homestead must know
PennsylvaniaEvery farm that spreads manure needs a written Manure Management Plan, even with one horse. You can write it yourself, and spreading with a pitchfork counts. Winter (Dec 15–Feb 28, or frozen or snowy ground) spreading is discouraged and capped. Field stacks 100 ft from water and wells; tarp them if left over 120 days
MarylandNo manure or fertilizer Dec 16–end of February, for all sizes. Plan required at $2,500 income or 8,000 lb of animals
VermontNo spreading Dec 15–Apr 1. Rules reach as few as 4 horses, 5 cattle or 15 goats on 4+ acres. Field stacks 200 ft from water and wells
WisconsinAll livestock keepers: no uncovered pile (175+ cu ft) within 300 ft of a stream or 1,000 ft of a lake
Ohio (western Lake Erie basin)No surface spreading on frozen, snowy or saturated soil, or with more than a 50% chance of over ½ in of rain within 24 hours
MinnesotaRegister a feedlot at 50 animal units (10 near lakes and streams). A horse is 1 unit. Pasture isn't a feedlot
IowaWinter rules cover only big liquid-manure confinement operations; small farms and solid manure are exempt
MichiganFollowing the voluntary Manure GAAMPs protects you from nuisance suits. Piles 150 ft from water, wells and non-farm homes
VirginiaAny farm can be ordered to make a plan after a pollution complaint
TexasManure stored over 30 days must be covered or in a runoff-controlled area. Keep a 100-ft vegetated buffer to water
ColoradoManure facilities at least 150 ft downgradient of wells; berm piles
WashingtonEvery licensed dairy needs a nutrient plan, even one cow. Counties like King County set lot sizes, setbacks and wet-season paddock cleaning

Your state may differ. Your state department of agriculture or local conservation district can tell you which rules apply to you.

Diagram coming soonWinter spreading map
Figure 10. Winter spreading bans in four states.
Sources: Code of Federal Regulations (eCFR), Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection and 12 more

What you'll need

ItemWhat it's forCost
Heavy tarp + weightsCovering piles; cuts N loss from about 31% to 10%—
Three-sided bin or bunker (wood, block or concrete)Containing and stacking manureNo price found in our sources
Pitchfork, wheelbarrow, 5-gallon bucketsMoving and measuring (bucket ≈ 25 lb)—
Kitchen or hanging scaleSpreader calibration, bucket weights—
Three tarps of known size (e.g. 6 × 6 ft)Spreader calibration—
Small ground-driven spreader (ATV or pickup)Spreading more than a few tons$1,600–$8,000 new in 2004 prices; used 50–60% of new
Manure testReal nutrient numbers$15–$81
Soil testSetting rates, watching PSee the Cover crops and soil tests lesson
Compost thermometerProving 131°FSee the Composting lesson
Gloves, closed-toe bootsHygiene—
Sources: Pacific Northwest Extension, North Carolina Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services and 1 more

Common mistakes

  1. Spreading fresh manure in spring on a vegetable garden. Fall application with 120/90 days to harvest is the rule.

  2. Calling an old pile "composted." Age isn't heat. Aged manure tested positive almost as often as fresh.

  3. Using rabbit or goat manure raw because it's "cold." "Cold" is about burning plants, not germs.

  4. Spreading by the truckload year after year. Phosphorus builds up. Rate it by a soil test.

  5. Leaving piles uncovered all winter. About a third of the nitrogen goes to the air and the P and K wash out.

  6. Putting the pile uphill of the well, or where roof water runs through it.

  7. Spreading on frozen ground. It runs off at snowmelt, and it's illegal in several states.

  8. Buying "composted" poultry litter that smells of ammonia. It's fresh litter.

  9. Spreading horse manure on horse pasture before it's fully composted. It spreads worms.

  10. Not knowing your state's rules. In Pennsylvania you need a written plan for even one horse.

Sources: Code of Federal Regulations (eCFR), Published research and 11 more

Troubleshooting

ProblemLikely causeFix
Plants yellow and stall after spreading horse manureWood shavings tying up nitrogenExpect 0–20% N in year one; add a quick N source; compost woody manure first
Seedlings burn or die after chicken manureSalt and ammonia in fresh poultry manureWait 3–4 weeks after applying before planting; use less
Tomatoes and beans with cupped, twisted leavesPersistent herbicide in manure, hay or compostPea pot test before using outside material; check the source's hay
Crust of white salt, poor water soak-in (dry West)Manure salts or sodiumCap at about 1 in a year; irrigate 4 in after; gypsum 50–100 lb per 1,000 sq ft
Soil test P keeps climbingNitrogen-based ratesSwitch to P-based rates; stop above 50 ppm Bray
Flies swarming the barnWet manure sitting over 7 days in warm weatherRemove or spread weekly; dry it; tarp or roof the pile
Dark runoff from the pile after rainNo cover, no diversionTarp; berm uphill; gutters; filter strip downhill
Neighbor complaintsPile near the property line or houseMove it 150–200 ft from homes; cover it; spread before warm weather
Sources: Pacific Northwest Extension, Oregon State University Extension and 11 more

Resources

By zone

Frozen ground, rain, heat and salty soils change how long you store manure and when you can spread it. Here is what shifts by zone and region.

3–4
Plan 180 days of storage. Ground stays frozen for months, and Vermont bans spreading Dec 15–Apr 1. Bacteria die off slowest in cold soil, so count your 120/90 days to harvest, not to spring.
5–6
About 180 days of storage. Winter bans in PA and MD, and Ohio's forecast rule. Fall manure on gardens, then a cover crop.
7–8
120–180 days of storage. Heavy rain washes P and K out of open piles, so roof or tarp them. Mid-Atlantic trials saw E. coli last past 90 days in most poultry-litter plots.
9–10
Short storage, but plan around the rainy season. Hot, dry weather strips up to 90% of the ammonium from surface manure, so work it in or spread before rain. In the arid West, cap manure at about 1 in a year because of salts. The longest fly season.
Northeast
the strictest small-farm rules (PA written plan; MD and VT winter bans). Chesapeake states limit P on high-P soils.
Southeast
high-P soils in the poultry belt, little N carryover from litter, and heavy rain on piles. Set rates by P and watch litter-fed forage minerals.
Midwest
frozen ground plus lake and stream rules (WI, OH, MN). Iowa's winter rules don't reach small farms.
Southwest
salts, sodium and fast ammonia loss. Texas limits uncovered storage to 30 days.
Pacific Northwest
wet winters leach N and wash out open piles. Spread in spring and cover piles. County rules on suburban horse lots.
Mountain West
dry air, salty soils, and well protection (Colorado's 150 ft).

Where this comes from

Every fact in this lesson was checked against 91 published sources, all from extension services, the USDA and research journals. Each section lists its own at the bottom.

See all 91 sources
Published research
Ask Extension / eXtension Foundation
Council of Bay Area Resource Conservation Districts
Pacific Northwest Extension
Penn State College of Agricultural Sciences Cooperative Extension
University of Delaware Extension
University of Florida IFAS Extension
University of Missouri Extension
USDA NRCS Alaska / Fairbanks SWCD

Summary

The whole lesson on one page. Print it or come back to it.

Key information

  • Waiting periods: raw manure goes on in fall, never on growing crops. Leave at least 120 days before harvesting anything that touches the soil and 90 days for crops held off the ground (USDA organic rule). FDA calls those intervals "prudent" but has set none of its own.
  • The 131°F rule: hot-compost chicken, turkey and duck manure (131°F for 3 days throughout) instead of waiting it out. In FDA's 2026 model, raw poultry manure stayed above compost-treated fields even at 120 days.
  • Aged is not composted. Manure aged 6–12 months tested positive for pathogens more often than manure aged 2–6 months.
  • No manure gets a pass. Rabbit, goat, sheep, horse and llama manure are all raw manure for food safety. Never use dog, cat, pig or human manure on food gardens.
  • Rate it by a soil test, not by the truckload. A manure test costs about $15–$81.
  • Store it covered and away from water: at least 150–200 ft from your well. A tarp cuts nitrogen loss from about 31% to about 10% over four months.

Step by step

  1. 1.Test your manure with 10–25 small scoops from many depths, and test your soil.
  2. 2.Set the rate from the tests, not by the truckload.
  3. 3.Spread raw manure in fall, work it in, and sow a cover crop. Never spread on frozen, snow-covered or saturated ground.
  4. 4.Count the 120 or 90 days to harvest, not to planting.
  5. 5.Use compost that met the heat standard in spring.

Made it to the end? I’ll keep track for you on this device.