Skip to content
Goshen Exchange

SustainabilityLesson 5 of 7

Cover crops and soil tests

Breakout About 11 min readNew to you

What you’ll learn

  • How to take a soil sample and what a lab test costs
  • How to read a report, and why many gardens should skip phosphorus
  • How to raise or lower pH, and when you can't
  • What to grow, and what to skip, if your soil has lead
  • Which cover crop to sow when, and how to end it without a tiller

The short version

  1. Test before you add anything. A lab test costs about $5–50. Home kits get pH within about a unit and are unreliable for phosphorus and potassium.

  2. Many gardens already have too much phosphorus. Minnesota's typical garden tests 68 ppm, against 26 on farms. Above about 25 ppm (Bray), skip phosphorus.

  3. Lime by the buffer pH, in fall, and no more than about 5 lb per 100 sq ft at a time. You can't acidify soil that fizzes with vinegar.

  4. Check for lead near old houses, busy roads and old orchards. Below 200 ppm, grow anything. At 200–1,200 ppm, skip leafy and root crops. Above that, use raised beds of clean soil.

  5. Keep something growing over winter. Sow cereal rye latest of all. Sow legumes 6–8 weeks before a killing frost. Kill rye only once it sheds pollen, then wait 3–4 weeks before sowing small seeds.

  6. Skip mycorrhizal inoculants. Most tested products had no live fungi. Less digging and living roots build your own.

Test your soil

Taking the sample

  1. When: fall is best in most places, because it gives lime time to work. In the arid West, Colorado State prefers spring.

  2. How often: every 3–5 years. Test every 1–3 years while you fix a problem or add a lot of manure or compost. Sample at the same time each year.

  3. Wait 6–8 weeks after liming or fertilizing, and don't sample soaking-wet soil.

  4. Tools: a clean plastic bucket and a rust-free trowel or probe. Not galvanized.

  5. Depth: dig to 6–8 in in gardens (3–4 in in pasture or no-till, 2–6 in for lawns). Take 12–20 cores across the area, skipping edges, paths and old compost-pile spots.

  6. Mix and dry: mix the cores, air-dry them without heat, and send 1–2 cups.

  7. Tell the lab what you'll grow, or you get numbers with no advice.

Sample beds you manage differently as separate samples.

What it costs (checked 2026-10-01)

LabPrice
North Carolina Dept. of AgricultureFree for residents April–November; $5 December–March
Clemson (SC)$6
UMass$20 routine, with a lead screen
Most labsAbout $15–50

Reading the report

  • Methods differ by region. Labs measure phosphorus with different chemicals, so you can't compare numbers across labs:

    • Bray: acid soils.
    • Olsen: alkaline soils (western labs).
    • Mehlich-3: much of the East.
    • Mehlich-1: the Southeast Coastal Plain.
    • Modified Morgan: New England.
  • Optimum, high or excessive means adding more won't help. The medium-to-high line is where crops hit about 90–95% of top yield.

  • Phosphorus is often already too high. Skip it above about 25 ppm Bray or 18 ppm Olsen. Feed nitrogen with feather or blood meal, and potassium with potassium sulfate.

  • Ignore "ideal calcium-to-magnesium ratios." Research doesn't support them. Fix only what tests low.

  • Organic matter is measured by weight. Even a rich garden often reads under 5%. About 2% or more is healthy for many soils, and raising it by 2 points is a big change.

  • Arid-West salts: a soil EC under 1.0 is fine, 1.0–2.5 is marginal, and over 2.5 is poor. High sodium breaks down soil structure; gypsum plus deep watering fixes it.

Diagram coming soonHow to take a soil sample
Figure 1. Twelve to twenty cores from across the bed, skipping edges, paths and old compost spots.
Diagram coming soonReading a soil report
Figure 2. What each line of a soil report means.
Sources: Clemson Extension, Colorado State University Extension and 10 more

Fix the pH

Targets

  • Most vegetables: about 6.0–7.0. Sources range from 5.5 to 7.0.

  • Blueberries, azaleas, rhododendrons: about 4.5–5.5.

  • Potatoes: keep them on the acid side. Scab worsens at higher pH, so don't lime or add wood ash to potato ground.

Raising pH (lime)

  • The buffer pH sets the rate, not the plain pH. A lower buffer reading means more lime. Clay and organic soils need more than sand.

  • Iowa State, to reach pH 6.5 (lb of pure lime per 1,000 sq ft):

Buffer pHLime
6.5about 64
6.0about 147
5.7about 197
  • Split big doses. Put no more than about 5 lb per 100 sq ft on the surface at once, or about 7 lb if you work it in. Spread the rest over seasons.

  • Give it time. Lime takes about 3–9 months, so apply it in fall and work it into moist soil.

  • Calcitic or dolomitic: use dolomitic only if magnesium tests low.

  • SAFETY: avoid hydrated (burned) lime. It burns skin and plants.

  • Wood ash is about half as strong as lime. Use no more than 15–20 lb per 1,000 sq ft a year, only from untreated wood, and keep it off seedlings, acid-loving plants and potatoes.

Lowering pH (sulfur)

  • Elemental sulfur works slowly, over months to a year:

    • Clemson: about 2 lb per 100 sq ft drops a loam from 6.5 to 5.5. Use a third less on sand and half again more on clay.
    • Iowa State: 15, 50 and 70 lb per 1,000 sq ft drop sandy loam, loam and clay loam from 6.5 to 4.5.
    • Split doses and retest.
  • Skip aluminum sulfate. It can injure roots.

  • The vinegar test: wet a spoonful of dry soil with vinegar. If it fizzes, the soil has free lime and can't practically be acidified. Grow blueberries in containers or raised beds of acid mix instead.

Gypsum

Gypsum doesn't change pH and doesn't loosen most clay. It helps sodic (salty-sodium) soils and maybe very heavy clays.

Diagram coming soonpH scale for the garden
Figure 3. Lime pushes pH up, sulfur pulls it down, and soil that fizzes with vinegar can't be acidified.
Diagram coming soonLime by buffer pH
Figure 4. Lime by buffer pH, in small doses.
Sources: University of Maine Extension, University of Maryland Extension and 9 more

Feed the soil, by the numbers

Fertilizer math

  • The label shows % nitrogen – % phosphate (P₂O₅) – % potash (K₂O).

  • Pounds of product = pounds of nutrient needed ÷ the fraction in the bag. Example: 2 lb of N from cottonseed meal (6% N) = 2 ÷ 0.06 ≈ 33 lb per 1,000 sq ft.

  • Per-acre rates: divide by 43.56 to get pounds per 1,000 sq ft.

How much nitrogen crops need (per 1,000 sq ft per season)

NeedCropsN
LowBeans, cucumbers, squashabout 3 lb
MediumTomatoes, peppers, onions, cornabout 4 lb
HighCabbage family, potatoesabout 5 lb

How fast organic fertilizers work

ProductN available in one season
Fish emulsionNearly all
Blood, feather, cottonseed mealAbout 75%
Bone mealAbout 30%
Alfalfa mealAbout 25%
Rock phosphateReleases P only below pH 6

They release slowly in cool spring and fall soil.

Compost

  • Coverage: one cubic yard covers about 600 sq ft at ½ in deep and gives about 2.5 lb of N per 1,000 sq ft the first season.

  • How much: Minnesota suggests about ½ in a year of non-manure compost. Sources disagree on rates.

  • Watch phosphorus with heavy compost (see the Mulch and no-till lesson).

Texture and compaction

  • Jar test:

    • Fill a quart jar a quarter full of soil.
    • Add water to three-quarters full, plus a teaspoon of non-foaming dishwasher detergent.
    • Shake 10–15 minutes.
    • Mark the sand after 1 minute, the silt after 2 hours, and the clay when the water clears (1–3 days).
    • Soil with as little as 20% clay acts like clay.
  • Compaction: if a stiff wire flag or welding rod is hard to push into the top 18–24 in, the soil is compacted. Roots stop at about 300 psi. Don't work wet soil.

Sources: Washington State University Extension, University of Minnesota Extension and 2 more

Lead and other contaminants

What to grow at each level (Oregon State)

Total leadWhat to do
Under 50 ppmNo special precautions
50–200 ppmGrow anything; limit dust and keep children from eating soil
200–1,200 ppmNo leafy greens or root crops
Over 1,200 ppmNo vegetables in the ground; raised beds or containers of clean soil

UMass draws its lines at 400 and 1,000 ppm.

Gardening on soil with some lead

  • Keep the pH near neutral (6.5–7.0) and add compost.

  • Mulch bare soil and paths.

  • Favor fruiting crops (tomatoes, squash, peas, corn) over leafy and root crops.

  • Wash produce well, peel root crops, and throw away outer leaves.

  • Wash hands, and keep children from eating soil. There is no known safe blood-lead level for children.

  • Safest of all: raised beds of clean soil over a barrier.

Treated wood

  • Old lumber: arsenic-treated (CCA) wood left home stores in December 2003, so lumber from before about 2004 may contain it.

    • Don't build beds from it or from railroad ties.
    • Don't burn it or use it as mulch.
  • Modern lumber: in a 4-year Oregon study, copper-azole lumber raised soil copper only within about an inch of the boards, with no increase in the vegetables.

Diagram coming soonLead decision ladder
Figure 5. What to grow at each level of lead.
Diagram coming soonRaised bed on suspect soil
Figure 6. A raised bed of clean soil over a barrier.
Sources: Oregon State University Extension, Code of Federal Regulations (eCFR) and 4 more

Cover crops

Pick by season and zone

CoverSurvives winter toUse it for
Cereal ryeZone 3Latest sowing, big biomass, catches leftover nitrogen
Hairy vetchZone 4Nitrogen; the hardiest legume
Crimson cloverDependable in zone 8, often lower zone 6; winterkills in zone 5 and colderNitrogen, early flowers
Oats, field peasWinterkill in most zones (oats to zone 8)Easy early-spring beds
Forage radishDies after nights below about 23°FBreaking compaction; clean beds in spring
Buckwheat, cowpeas, sorghum-sudangrass, sunn hempNo frostSummer gaps

Sowing

  • Garden rates (oz per 100 sq ft):

    • Cereal rye or oats: 4–6
    • Buckwheat: 3–4
    • Crimson clover: 2–3
    • Hairy vetch: 2
    • Radish: 1
    • For a two-species mix, sow about 60% of each.
  • Depth: about ¼–½ in for clover and radish, ½–1½ in for vetch, ¾–2 in for rye, and 1½–3 in for peas. Sow pre-inoculated seed about a third heavier by weight.

  • Inoculate legumes with the matching group: pea/vetch, crimson/berseem, or cowpea (also used for sunn hemp). Check the date on the bag.

When to sow

  • Legumes: 6–8 weeks before a killing frost. Hairy vetch needs at least 30–45 days.

  • Non-legumes: 4–6 weeks before.

  • Radish: about 4 weeks before the first 28°F freeze.

  • Cereal rye: can go in latest, up to mid-November in South Carolina.

  • Summer covers: buckwheat after frost danger; cowpeas and sunn hemp in soil 65°F or warmer.

What you get

  • Nitrogen: legume covers hold about 1.6–4.6 lb of nitrogen per 1,000 sq ft. Only about half or less reaches the next crop, up to about 2.3 lb per 1,000 sq ft. Most is released within 4 weeks of killing the cover.

  • When to kill for nitrogen: legumes at about bud stage; cereals young, at jointing. Left to mature, cereals tie up nitrogen.

Ending a cover without a tiller

  1. Rye and wheat: cut, mow or crimp them only when they're shedding pollen. Cut earlier, they regrow.

    • Pollen shed came about early May in Virginia and late May–early June in Pennsylvania, Vermont and Iowa.
  2. Or smother it: a black tarp kills rye in about 3 weeks from late April to mid-May.

  3. Leave the cuttings on top as mulch. In raised beds, cut at the base with shears at about half to full bloom.

  4. Wait before planting: about 2–4 weeks. After rye, wait 3–4 weeks before direct-seeding small seeds like carrots and lettuce; rye residue holds them back for about a month. Transplants and big seeds cope better.

Diagram coming soonCover-crop hardiness map
Figure 7. Where each cover crop survives the winter.
Diagram coming soonCover-crop calendar
Figure 8. Sow legumes 6 to 8 weeks before a killing frost; end the cover at pollen shed.
Diagram coming soonRye growth stages
Figure 9. Cut rye at pollen shed, not before.
Diagram coming soonLegume nitrogen budget
Figure 10. How much nitrogen a legume cover leaves for the next crop.
Sources: SARE (USDA), Clemson Extension and 9 more

What you'll need

ItemNotes
Soil probe or trowel, clean plastic bucket, zip bagsFor sampling; no galvanized metal
Lab soil test$5–50; add total lead in older neighborhoods
Calcitic or dolomitic lime, elemental sulfurBy soil test only
Cover-crop seed and legume inoculantMatched inoculant group; check the date
Shears, string trimmer or mowerEnding covers without a tiller
Quart jar, dishwasher detergentJar test

Common mistakes

  1. Fertilizing without a test, especially adding phosphorus to a garden that already has too much.

  2. Trusting a home kit for P and K.

  3. Dumping a whole lime recommendation at once, or in spring right before planting.

  4. Trying to acidify soil that fizzes with vinegar.

  5. Buying gypsum to loosen clay, or amendments to hit a calcium-to-magnesium ratio.

  6. Growing leafy and root crops in leaded soil near old houses or roads without testing.

  7. Raised beds from old pressure-treated lumber or railroad ties.

  8. Mowing rye before it sheds pollen. It regrows.

  9. Direct-seeding carrots right after rye.

  10. Letting vetch or buckwheat go to seed.

  11. Mycorrhizal inoculant in ordinary garden soil.

Sources: University of Minnesota Extension, South Dakota State University Extension and 10 more

Troubleshooting

ProblemLikely causeFix
Seeds fail after a rye coverRye residue suppressing small seedsWait 3–4 weeks or use transplants
Rye regrew after mowingCut before pollen shedCut again at flowering, or tarp
Sulfur did nothingFree lime in soilVinegar test; containers or raised beds
pH barely changed after limeToo soon, not mixed inWait 3–9 months; work into moist soil
P keeps climbing on soil testsManure or compostPlant-based compost; skip P fertilizer
White crust, water won't soak in (West)Salts or sodiumTest EC and sodium; gypsum plus deep watering
Sources: SARE (USDA), University of Vermont Extension, Northwest Crops and Soils Program and 5 more

Resources

By zone

Soil tests, pH and cover-crop sowing dates all shift with climate. Here is what changes by zone and region.

3–4
Oats and peas July 10–Sept 1; hairy vetch by mid-August; rye to about Oct 20.
5–6
Rye by mid-September on the Colorado Front Range; vetch at least 30–45 days before killing frost. Rye sheds pollen late May–early June; tarp from late April if you need the bed sooner.
7–8
South Carolina sows legumes Aug–Oct, rye to mid-November, and summer covers Apr–Sept.
9–10
Sunn hemp after last frost in Florida. Desert winter covers late Nov–early Dec with irrigation.
Northeast
acid soils. Lime by buffer pH; Modified Morgan tests in New England; black tarps.
Southeast
acid sandy soils and cheap tests (NC free most of the year).
Midwest
gardens are often far too high in phosphorus. Rye crimped about June 3 in Iowa.
Southwest
alkaline soils you can't acidify, plus salts and sodium.
Pacific Northwest
acid west of the Cascades, alkaline east. Sow covers late Aug–Sept; slugs under mulch.
Mountain West
low organic matter. Sow covers by mid-September (August in the mountains); no combustible mulch near buildings in wildfire country.

Where this comes from

Every fact in this lesson was checked against 54 published sources: 53 from extension services, the USDA and research journals and 1 from experienced growers and practitioners. Each section lists its own at the bottom.

See all 54 sources
New Mexico State University Extension
North Carolina Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services
South Dakota State University Extension
U.S. EPA Office of Pesticide Programs
UConn Extension
University of Vermont Extension, Northwest Crops and Soils Program
University of Wisconsin Extension
Washington State Department of Ecology

Summary

The whole lesson on one page. Print it or come back to it.

Key information

  • Test before you add anything. A lab test costs about $5–50. Home kits get pH within about a unit and are unreliable for phosphorus and potassium.
  • Many gardens already have too much phosphorus. Above about 25 ppm (Bray), skip phosphorus.
  • Lime by the buffer pH, in fall, and no more than about 5 lb per 100 sq ft at a time. You can't acidify soil that fizzes with vinegar.
  • Check for lead near old houses, busy roads and old orchards. Below 200 ppm, grow anything. At 200–1,200 ppm, skip leafy and root crops.
  • Keep something growing over winter. Sow legumes 6–8 weeks before a killing frost and cereal rye latest of all. Kill rye only once it sheds pollen, then wait 3–4 weeks before sowing small seeds.
  • Skip mycorrhizal inoculants. Most tested products had no live fungi.

Step by step

  1. 1.Dig 12–20 cores, 6–8 in deep, with a clean plastic bucket and a rust-free trowel.
  2. 2.Mix the cores, air-dry them without heat, and send 1–2 cups. Tell the lab what you will grow.
  3. 3.Lime by the buffer pH in fall, no more than about 5 lb per 100 sq ft at a time.
  4. 4.Ask for total lead if you garden near an old house, a busy road or old orchard land.
  5. 5.Sow a cover crop: legumes 6–8 weeks before a killing frost, cereal rye latest of all.

Made it to the end? I’ll keep track for you on this device.