Skip to content
Goshen Exchange

SustainabilityLesson 6 of 7

Mulch and no-till

Breakout About 5 min readNew to you

What you’ll learn

  • Which mulch and how deep for beds, paths, trees and slopes
  • Why every organic mulch burns, and how far to keep it from the house
  • How to build a no-dig bed, and what the research says about it
  • How black tarps and clear plastic kill weeds, and how long it takes
  • Why heavy compost every year can overload phosphorus

The short version

  1. Mulch to the job. Use 1–2 in of compost on beds, wood chips in paths and around perennials, and nothing combustible within 5 ft of the house.

  2. No-dig builds soil structure and soil life. Yield gains are mixed, and heavy compost every year can overload phosphorus.

Mulch guide

MulchWhereDepthNotes
Compost, leaf moldVegetable beds1–2 in—
Grass clippingsVegetable bedsLayers of ¼ in or less, about 2 in totalNever from lawns sprayed in the past month
StrawVegetable beds2–4 inWeed-seed-free; ask whether the field was sprayed with a persistent herbicide
Wood chipsPaths, perennials, fruit trees3–4 in (4–6 in for weed control)Not in annual beds; never dig them in
Pine strawShrubs, slopesUp to about 5 in—
Black plasticWarm-season crops—Warms soil about 5°F; lay 1–2 weeks before planting
  • Wood chips and nitrogen: chips on the surface don't starve trees or shrubs, and over time they enrich the soil. But a thin nitrogen-poor layer forms where they meet the soil, which is why they stunt vegetable seedlings.

  • Cold zones: wait until the soil has warmed before putting organic mulch around warm-season crops. Mulch keeps soil cool.

  • Desert: 2 in of chips cut 22-day water loss by more than half and kept soil 2 in down below 104°F in Phoenix.

  • No volcanoes: keep a bare ring around tree trunks (6 in, Minnesota).

  • Landscape fabric works as a seasonal cover or a tarp, but fails as a permanent layer under mulch.

  • Sour mulch smells of vinegar or rotten eggs and burns plants. Spread it out to air for about 3 days first.

Diagram coming soonMulch depth chart
Figure 1. How deep each mulch goes, and where.
Diagram coming soonDefensible space around the house
Figure 2. Keep the first 5 ft around the house free of combustible mulch.
Diagram coming soonTree mulch right and wrong
Figure 3. A bare ring at the trunk, never a volcano.
Sources: Colorado State University Extension, Clemson Extension and 8 more

Pests under mulch

  • Slugs hide under mulch. Trap them under boards and pick them off in the morning. September–October and early spring are the best times to control them.

  • Voles nest in mulch at tree bases in winter:

    • Pull mulch back, or lay a ring of gravel 3–4 in deep reaching 15–18 in from the trunk.
    • Guard young trees with ¼-in hardware cloth, 18–24 in high and set 4–6 in into the ground.
Sources: Penn State Extension

No-dig beds

  1. Start a bed (Charles Dowding, a long-time no-dig grower):

    • Lay cardboard over the weeds and cover it with about 6 in of compost, well trodden.
    • Annual weeds die in 2–3 months; many perennials take about 6.
    • Put black plastic over heavy bindweed or couch grass first.
  2. Top it up. In Dowding's trial beds he added about 2.5 in a year in years two and three, then about an inch a year.

  3. Cardboard alone isn't enough. It rots in months and running grasses push through, so always cover it with organic matter.

What the research shows:

  • Soil life and structure: less tillage reliably builds them. After 19 years in the Great Plains, no-till topsoil held together 2–7 times better in rain. Across studies, no-till raised earthworm numbers by about 137%.

  • Yield is mixed:

    • Organic field trials averaged 7.6% lower yields with reduced tillage versus deep plowing, and no loss versus shallow tillage.
    • Dowding's single 13-year bed pair found no-dig about 13% higher.
  • Heavy compost overloads phosphorus. In New York and Maine, 1.5 in a year of manure compost raised organic matter and yields, but pushed soil phosphorus up eightfold in 4 years. Test your soil, and switch to plant-based compost if phosphorus runs high.

  • Roller-crimping needs a tractor and flowering rye, so gardeners cut or tarp instead.

  • A broadfork loosens soil with little disturbance but is hard work.

Diagram coming soonNo-dig bed build
Figure 4. Cardboard, then about 6 in of compost, then wait.
Sources: Charles Dowding, Oregon State University Extension and 6 more

Tarps and solarization

  • Black tarp (occultation):

    • How long: in summer, annual weeds die in under a week; in cool seasons it takes up to 3 weeks. Three weeks killed 95% or more of emerged weeds in New York trials. Sod takes 4–6 weeks or more.
    • Tough grasses: bermudagrass and johnsongrass took 14–16 weeks in Virginia, and nutsedge survived.
  • Materials (2022 prices for about 32 × 100 ft):

    • 5–6 mil silage tarp: $130–202, lasts 3–5 years.
    • Woven fabric: $184–224.
    • Clear 6-mil plastic: $253–535.
    • Weigh the edges with 10–15 lb sandbags every 5 ft.
  • Drawbacks: rodents (then snakes) move in, water ponds, and nitrate builds up underneath.

  • Clear plastic (solarization):

    • Wet the soil to about 12 in.
    • Cover it tightly with clear plastic and bury the edges.
    • Leave it 4–6 weeks in the hottest weather. The top 2 in reach about 108–140°F.
    • It works best in hot interior and desert areas. In the cool Northeast, clear plastic often grows weeds, so use black.
Diagram coming soonTarp and solarization guide
Figure 5. How long black and clear plastic take to work.
Sources: University of Maine Extension, Virginia Cooperative Extension and 3 more

What you'll need

ItemNotes
Silage tarp (5–6 mil) and sandbags$130–202 for about 32 × 100 ft (2022)
Clear 1–4 mil plasticSolarization in hot zones
Compost, leaf mold, straw, wood chipsMulches by job (table above)
¼-in hardware clothVole guards

Common mistakes

  1. Wood chips dug into vegetable beds.

  2. Bark or rubber mulch against the house.

  3. Inches of manure compost every year without testing phosphorus.

Sources: Washington State University Extension, University of Nevada Cooperative Extension / UC Cooperative Extension and 1 more

Troubleshooting

ProblemLikely causeFix
Yellow seedlings in a wood-chip bedNitrogen-poor layer under chipsKeep chips to paths; use compost on beds
Slugs everywhere under mulchShelterBoard traps; fall and early-spring control
Tree bark chewed at ground level in springVoles under mulch or snowGravel ring, hardware-cloth guard
Weeds through landscape fabricMulch on top of fabricRemove fabric; use mulch alone
Grass under the tarp still alivePerennial warm-season grass14–16 weeks, during active growth
Sources: Washington State University Extension, Oregon State University Extension and 2 more

Resources

By zone

Soil temperature, rainfall, termites and fire risk change how you mulch. Here is what shifts by zone and region.

3–4
Wait for warm soil before mulching. Winter-mulch strawberries after 3 days of soil at or below 40°F. Black tarps over clear plastic. Voles under snow.
5–6
Rye sheds pollen late May–early June; tarp from late April if you need the bed sooner.
7–8
Mulch breaks down fast in the Southeast. Bermudagrass needs 14–16 weeks under a tarp. Thin mulch near foundations for termites.
9–10
Mulch keeps desert soil below 104°F. Solarization works best here.
Southeast
Fast mulch breakdown; termites.
Southwest
Mulch saves water; solarization works.
Pacific Northwest
Sow covers late Aug–Sept; slugs under mulch.
Mountain West
Sow covers by mid-September (August in the mountains); no combustible mulch near buildings in wildfire country.

Where this comes from

Every fact in this lesson was checked against 28 published sources: 24 from extension services, the USDA and research journals, 3 from experienced growers and practitioners and 1 from grower forums, where several agreed. Each section lists its own at the bottom.

See all 28 sources
Clemson Extension
Colorado State University Extension
Rodale Institute
University of California Agriculture and Natural Resources
University of Florida IFAS Extension
University of Georgia Extension
University of Nevada Cooperative Extension / UC Cooperative Extension
USDA Agricultural Research Service

Summary

The whole lesson on one page. Print it or come back to it.

Key information

  • Mulch to the job. Compost 1–2 in on beds; straw 2–4 in; wood chips 3–4 in on paths, perennials and fruit trees, never in annual beds and never dug in.
  • Every organic mulch burned in Nevada fire tests. Keep the first 5 ft around buildings free of it.
  • Within 12 in of the foundation, use less than 2 in of mulch or none, and keep a 6-in gap below siding.
  • No-dig: cardboard, then about 6 in of compost. Annual weeds die in 2–3 months and many perennials take about 6. Cardboard alone isn't enough.
  • No-dig yield gains are mixed. Less tillage reliably builds soil structure and soil life.
  • Heavy compost overloads phosphorus. Test your soil, and switch to plant-based compost if phosphorus runs high.

Step by step

  1. 1.Lay cardboard over the weeds. Put black plastic over heavy bindweed or couch grass first.
  2. 2.Cover it with about 6 in of compost, well trodden.
  3. 3.Wait 2–3 months for annual weeds to die, and about 6 for many perennials.
  4. 4.Top it up each year: about 2.5 in in years two and three, then about an inch a year.
  5. 5.Test your soil, and switch to plant-based compost if phosphorus runs high.

Made it to the end? I’ll keep track for you on this device.